Sunday, February 21, 2010

HW 40 - School Interviews and Synthesis

Part A:

In all of my interviews, I started off very basic by asking them to tell me about their experience as a student. From there, I sort of just asked follow up questions on the spot. I also listed their high schools and year of attendance because I realized that the setting plays a big role on their thoughts about school. I interviewed Jon (Hill) because I thought it was interesting to see his perspectives on the relationship (if any) between schooling in France vs. schooling here. My grandmother who made it to 4th grade only, my father who made it to 11th grade, his girlfriend who finished high school and college and became a teacher for elementary kids, and her son who currently attends high school. Everyone talked about their overall experience even if I asked questions that seemed to focus on just the ideas.

Notes:

Name, Age, School, Year of high school attendance

Adam, 17, Leadership and Public Service, 2006-10: School sucks, I hate it. We have tests and quizzes every other day. Homework every single day. No gym and the lunch is terrible. Teachers suck. They’re always yelling. Hate the rules – No chewing gum, no hats. They do it to try and make everything right. Their life sucks, take anger out on us. They have nothing better to do. Likes: Sports, school parties, dean (he’s ‘cool’), friends. Teachers barely help. Everyone thinks they give us an education but they don’t teach anything that ‘sticks’. Their teaching isn’t good enough. I would like for them to talk to me about what I can do to succeed. 30 kids to a classroom. They just want money. After schools done, my teachers are nowhere to be found. I think school makes my behavior worse. All the yelling makes me tense up. My old school (Tito Puente) was definitely better. Teachers were cool. Lunch was better. Big school. Big gym. I was a better person. I was better in sports.

Dad, 52, Seward Park, ~1973: School was fun. Great teachers. Great classmates. Teachers worked with you. Took time out for you, they cared. Classmates were funny and helpful. At the time, Vietnam was over and people were still talking about it. Made people closer – sort of like a family. Disliked the racism. Racist kids would beat up on one kid. Teachers mostly stood out of outside school issues. High school teachers played favoritism. Of course I wasn’t a favorite. With time education got better. There was no computer access. A lot slower. Todays school system is better – information at your fingertips. Before it was so much to do research. I stopped school because of the money I was making working with my father as a carpenter. I loved it though. I do wish I finished it. It helped me because it made me appreciate learning more. We didn’t have that many tests or quizzes. Never a lot of homework. More physical. Hands on.

Sally, 52, Mable Dean Bacon, 1973-77: Wonderful. All girls school. No distractions (no boys). Spent time with teachers. Wasn’t overcrowded. They cared. About 18 or so kids to a class. Teachers made it fun and interesting. We had to do and learn things ourselves. No computers. More research. Teachers made it so that we want to come back. I look at you guys today and you all hate school. I never liked math. They taught it well I just never liked it because I still couldn’t grasp everything. Afterschool my teacher worked with me one on one. I always wanted to learn. It made me want to further my education. Wasn’t about materials and who wore what. Everyone wanted to learn and that’s what they were there for. Once you got a degree, you knew you had a job, now it’s more about who you know. People with masters can’t find jobs. For teachers it wasn’t about money. They did more volunteering if anything. Less stressful before.

Grandma, 71, N/A, Would have been around 1946ish: I made it up to 4th grade. Don’t remember much. I learned how to read and write. I learned everything on my own (through experience and just growing up). Very poor. Spent days trading food. Learned how to cook by her mother. I think school is very important and I tried to get my kids to go to school to get a good job. School gives you education and opens opportunities. Maybe if I stayed in school who knows what I could have done with my life. Better off if I had gone to school. I married a man who supported me and our family. I never needed to work. My job was to cook and raise the children. I took care of the house. During the time I should have been in school, I was helping raise my baby sister.

Jon, 17, School of the Future/Lycee Jean Victor Poncelet, 2006-10: Being a student hasn't been anything monumental in my life. I'd describe myself as someone who's very curious and who enjoys learning but I'm in a bit of a catch 22. I like structure, and think that school should make disciplined students, but feel that too much discipline is bad but when given too much freedom, I slack off. I think there should be a healthy medium. In France, formalized education is very, very important. Students have a lot of difficulty adapting to a system that fosters a gap between students and professors. In France, the teacher is always right, and isn't committed to the student outside of their job descriptions: they get paid to teach, not to be life mentors. Relationships are very impersonal there. At sof however, it's almost the opposite. We call our teachers by their first names, we curse whenever we want, we lack respect so there needs to be a balance. I think that schooling now incorporates ideas that weren't considered as important before. Schools nowadays act as community centers, and teachers are called on to provide assistance to students well beyond the realms of simply "teaching". Teachers used to be considered authority figures, and were only there to do their job. Now, teachers become informal guidance counselors, and at younger and younger ages, students become informal with their elders but the ideas of discipline are being lost because everyone is becoming so much more informal so I think school systems need to backtrack a little bit in order to reinstall respect into the minds of the youth.

Part B:

One of the most important factors that can affect the whole outlook of school is how much the teacher cares. It means more to children if they’re enthusiastic about teaching. If they are willing to give up time after school or even work with you one on one you feel better, than you’re much more motivated. People generally don’t respond well to disappointment so if teachers cared about the students more often, students would feel pressured into not letting them down and striving for their best. They would also be much more likely to do homework at home resulting in preparation for the class and an overall higher understanding of the class work. Classmates are mainly on the side. They’re fun to be around and can make your school experience better if you make good friends but overall they’re nothing special. When teachers care, students care. Teachers who show that they’re only there for the money and who aren’t so much willing to help out enforce children to not care and do other things as well.

If school was based more on what children like (gym), and had better food, children would refer to school as a happier environment making it a place they like to come to and like to consider as a second home. If respect wasn’t such a big deal and people found a ‘healthy medium’ that both kids and teachers could agree on, then school would be much more of a likeable place. It’s simple things like being a teacher who cares, good food, more time to be physically active, and demanded less obedience, school would be a place kids would gladly wake up bright and early for.

No comments:

Post a Comment