Our class didn’t successfully complete a savior/teacher film so I watched the other class’s film but I genuinely liked ours better. So I’m choosing to do my homework on our unfinished film.
My personal contribution to the film really wasn’t much. I was ‘cast’ as Alex – the bad ass girl who’s stupid and never really tries (although in the end she proves to herself that if she actually tries, she is more than capable). The first day of filming was a really productive filming day. The second day – not so much. The third day I was absent and the fourth day I voted to just move on.
One reason I really liked our film was because of the message. I think for the most part it was original and I can’t exactly name a movie off the top of my head that ends like our movie/ anything like that. In our film, Alex starts off never willing to do anything about her teachers ‘unfairness’. She doesn’t study but instead complains about her teacher not treating her very nice and having his favorites (the teachers pet – Casey and her friends). In my opinion, I kind of believe that’s her fault. I don’t think he should have said certain things about her in front of the class to the other students but I think he has a right to not be nice to her. I feel like all a teacher wants from the student is to try. Although we may not want to be there, they do. They chose to teach. And if all they want is for us to try, then why not try. At the very least, a little. The next scene in the film was supposed to be Alex having flashbacks of all the things the teacher said (ending up in Burger King, etc) and even what Casey said to her (about trying harder). She takes this into consideration and studies with her friends. From what I understand, Alex and her friends do it for themselves. To prove to themselves that they can do it if they tried. That they’re really not stupid. When it comes time to take the test, because they got everything right on the test, the teacher thinks they cheated and demands they re-take the test. At first they are reluctant to taking the test but they re-take it because they know they haven’t cheated. Even as the teachers watching them take the test they ace it. The teacher has nothing to say to them. He’s shocked. Then Fanning comes in and congratulates the teacher for really turning the kids around. The teacher proudly accepts his praise but Alex and her friends know better. Although they don’t say anything to the teacher, they know it was nothing the teacher did, it was in themselves the whole time.
I think our film is quite different from the other films because the teacher in the films genuinely cared about their classes. They always wanted better for them and couldn’t understand why they were so unwilling to take part in class and do the work, etc. Our teacher in this film didn’t really care but instead just made it an example. He presented an attitude of “…you don’t want to end up like Alex now, do you?” He didn’t really try to connect with her or make her step outside of her box. He didn’t suggest trying harder, Casey did. The teacher just kept pushing Alex down. He never tried to pick her up. And in this film, the teacher gets glorified by the principal for his efforts making him a clear asshole because he knows he had nothing/very little to do with the change in Alex and her friends.
I think in order to be a good teacher (connecting with the students and helping them to want to learn), you have to have (even if it’s a little bit) the salvation element. Not always in the sense of relating school to the immanence-style of teaching, but just in the sense that having an education, whether we like it or not, matters a lot. We really cant get anywhere in life without it (unless you have a special talent or some really redeeming qualities etc, but not everyone has one so…). Your education is what people will judge you on for the rest of your life. Even when you apply to your job – they have a whole section on Education. Even when people ask you the name of your college – they’re looking to judge you. If they didn’t care, they simply wouldn’t ask.
In general though, here at SOF I feel like part of the reason why this school has a lot of good teachers is because they actually care. It’s not like they’re just asking us to read this and do this ... they want us to think. When a teacher here asks a question, they’ll wait for you to answer it. They’ll make you look back in your notes for it. Show you example problems; encourage you to come after school. There’s really no reason why you should be failing here. They give you many opportunities and they’re very understanding about everything. As many times as we may have already heard it – we really do have it easy here at SOF. Sadly I realized that, and still haven’t taken advantage of that, but that’s my own fault.
Friday, April 23, 2010
Wednesday, April 14, 2010
HW 48
* Film will focus on one specific teacher-student relationship
Class including teacher are watching Freedom Writers. Movie is finishing and the credits role. Teacher and students are touched by the heart warming film in which they have not analyzed. All stand up while one student turns the light back on. Teacher says "goodbye, hope you all enjoyed the film" to students and "see you all tomorrow".
At home, main student wishes their school experience to be similar to that in the movie: hero teacher saves hopeless children. Student then creates home problems for them self.
Next day student goes in to see teacher about home problems before class starts. Teacher knows he cannot help but still accepts the open invitation to become closer to the student (secretly wanting to be the hero but never really willing to admit it). Teacher offers suggestions on how to solve problems. Student is satisfied with teacher's attempt and leaves.
Later in the day passing in hallway, teacher tells student to check email. Email read something along the lines of "I want you to be open with me. Talk about your problems... etc etc". Student writes back, making up more problems but feeling saved by "concerned" teacher.
Emails go on until students friend snoops through the emails and realizes not only that student is lying but that the relationship growing between the two is unfair. Students friend noticed that ever since emails began, student has been doing super well in teachers class. Students friend shows emails to principal. Principal finds it inappropriate and calls in parents. Student is exposed of the lies and teacher feels selfishly ripped off. Student doesn't return to school and after about a month, teacher begins writing emails. This time, there's a real problem...
Class including teacher are watching Freedom Writers. Movie is finishing and the credits role. Teacher and students are touched by the heart warming film in which they have not analyzed. All stand up while one student turns the light back on. Teacher says "goodbye, hope you all enjoyed the film" to students and "see you all tomorrow".
At home, main student wishes their school experience to be similar to that in the movie: hero teacher saves hopeless children. Student then creates home problems for them self.
Next day student goes in to see teacher about home problems before class starts. Teacher knows he cannot help but still accepts the open invitation to become closer to the student (secretly wanting to be the hero but never really willing to admit it). Teacher offers suggestions on how to solve problems. Student is satisfied with teacher's attempt and leaves.
Later in the day passing in hallway, teacher tells student to check email. Email read something along the lines of "I want you to be open with me. Talk about your problems... etc etc". Student writes back, making up more problems but feeling saved by "concerned" teacher.
Emails go on until students friend snoops through the emails and realizes not only that student is lying but that the relationship growing between the two is unfair. Students friend noticed that ever since emails began, student has been doing super well in teachers class. Students friend shows emails to principal. Principal finds it inappropriate and calls in parents. Student is exposed of the lies and teacher feels selfishly ripped off. Student doesn't return to school and after about a month, teacher begins writing emails. This time, there's a real problem...
Extra Credit - "The Class"
At School of The Future, classrooms range from being very different to the class in the movie and being one in the same. It depends on who the teacher is and how they demand their respect (if at all), what class it is (if the class is going to give students actual credit or if it’s just a nonsense class), and most importantly – which students you have in your class. Students tend to push teachers to their limits to see how much they can get away with, etc. The response of the teacher paves the student’s work ethics in class for the rest of the year. For example, if the teacher is overwhelmed or looks nervous being there – then students know they can take advantage.
Contrary to the movie, a typical day at SOF doesn’t quite begin the same way. Yes, students walk in talking, making jokes, not paying attention, etc but usually it doesn’t take very long for us to settle down and begin to pay attention. However, students at SOF do have the same characteristics as those in the movie; smartasses who question what the teacher is teaching. The vibe in the movie was mainly that the students were smartasses for entertainment. Just as in SOF, we’re smartasses to waste time. We think if we can keep the teacher talking, off subject of course, then we have succeeded. Most times – teachers fall for it. We all get the feeling teachers know what we’re doing but in my opinion, teachers find their time better spent if they talk (specifically about themselves).
Just as the teacher called the two class representatives skanks or whatever, kids at SOF are also insulted by teachers. Teachers at SOF are smarter than the teacher in the movie though because they manipulate their words so that if they do insult students, they can get away with it. Here, they like to make witty comments. In the movie, he let his anger/frustration get the best of him and bluntly said it. But also, students don’t run and tell people about what teacher said “this”. I think here, it’s more common for students to be embarrassed and keep it to themselves or just share it with friends. If they do tell, they were probably out to get “revenge” on the teacher (and it has happened).
At the end of the movie, Souleymane got expelled for constantly being disruptive and taking violent action (when his book bag hit the girl in the face). Although the teacher knew his consequence of potentially being sent off back to his home island, the teacher pursued his choice guiltily and of course, Souleymane gets sent back. There are certain students at SOF that are constantly disruptive but don’t take violent action. SOF students are all about the verbal punches instead of physical ones. I think the violence Souleymane took is what set the teachers off and allowed them to expel him. If a student here were to just constantly be disruptive, SOF really doesn’t do anything about it (besides sometimes throwing them out of class). I guess in a way its equal to the punishment a teacher gets if they insult a student here (pretty much nothing).
It was childish for the teacher to come out to the girls the way he did but I still don’t think that it justifies them telling Souleymane lies. You could tell the teacher felt sympathy for him during the meeting and tried to make the report sound as well as it could, so for the girls to make it seem as if the teacher called him a retard was uncalled for. If it wasn’t for them, none of it would have happened in the first place. Even though the teacher lashed out, it seemed okay for the most part by all the other faculty who told him “it happens”. They weren’t saying anything about how bags accidentally hit people just “happens”. If that were to happen here, I think the same kinds of action that took place would have occurred. Teacher wouldn’t have gotten I trouble, student would’ve. Point blank. And that has mostly to do with the fact that teachers do indeed have more power than students. That’s why we’re the ones with the consequences to pay and the teachers aren’t. When’s the last time a teacher actually got in trouble ... like official trouble? ... I’ve never heard.
I honestly don’t think SOF’s that bad of an “institution”. It’s very welcoming and open-minded to students and their opinions. Of course there are right and wrong answers but for the most part teachers don’t really care about that here. It’s more about having a try your best type of attitude and you’ll be fine. Just don’t try to battle the teacher. It rarely ends up in your favor.
Contrary to the movie, a typical day at SOF doesn’t quite begin the same way. Yes, students walk in talking, making jokes, not paying attention, etc but usually it doesn’t take very long for us to settle down and begin to pay attention. However, students at SOF do have the same characteristics as those in the movie; smartasses who question what the teacher is teaching. The vibe in the movie was mainly that the students were smartasses for entertainment. Just as in SOF, we’re smartasses to waste time. We think if we can keep the teacher talking, off subject of course, then we have succeeded. Most times – teachers fall for it. We all get the feeling teachers know what we’re doing but in my opinion, teachers find their time better spent if they talk (specifically about themselves).
Just as the teacher called the two class representatives skanks or whatever, kids at SOF are also insulted by teachers. Teachers at SOF are smarter than the teacher in the movie though because they manipulate their words so that if they do insult students, they can get away with it. Here, they like to make witty comments. In the movie, he let his anger/frustration get the best of him and bluntly said it. But also, students don’t run and tell people about what teacher said “this”. I think here, it’s more common for students to be embarrassed and keep it to themselves or just share it with friends. If they do tell, they were probably out to get “revenge” on the teacher (and it has happened).
At the end of the movie, Souleymane got expelled for constantly being disruptive and taking violent action (when his book bag hit the girl in the face). Although the teacher knew his consequence of potentially being sent off back to his home island, the teacher pursued his choice guiltily and of course, Souleymane gets sent back. There are certain students at SOF that are constantly disruptive but don’t take violent action. SOF students are all about the verbal punches instead of physical ones. I think the violence Souleymane took is what set the teachers off and allowed them to expel him. If a student here were to just constantly be disruptive, SOF really doesn’t do anything about it (besides sometimes throwing them out of class). I guess in a way its equal to the punishment a teacher gets if they insult a student here (pretty much nothing).
It was childish for the teacher to come out to the girls the way he did but I still don’t think that it justifies them telling Souleymane lies. You could tell the teacher felt sympathy for him during the meeting and tried to make the report sound as well as it could, so for the girls to make it seem as if the teacher called him a retard was uncalled for. If it wasn’t for them, none of it would have happened in the first place. Even though the teacher lashed out, it seemed okay for the most part by all the other faculty who told him “it happens”. They weren’t saying anything about how bags accidentally hit people just “happens”. If that were to happen here, I think the same kinds of action that took place would have occurred. Teacher wouldn’t have gotten I trouble, student would’ve. Point blank. And that has mostly to do with the fact that teachers do indeed have more power than students. That’s why we’re the ones with the consequences to pay and the teachers aren’t. When’s the last time a teacher actually got in trouble ... like official trouble? ... I’ve never heard.
I honestly don’t think SOF’s that bad of an “institution”. It’s very welcoming and open-minded to students and their opinions. Of course there are right and wrong answers but for the most part teachers don’t really care about that here. It’s more about having a try your best type of attitude and you’ll be fine. Just don’t try to battle the teacher. It rarely ends up in your favor.
Monday, April 12, 2010
47 - Class Film Preparation 1
- Students giving teacher homework, and only when he completes those assignments - they do his work
- Teacher always making things seem better (always on trips or something.. showing them stuff that relates to them and applying it to their importance) ... making things better but clearly not the solution.
- SILENT FILMS ( always fun plus very exaggerated facial expressions make everyone's overall interpretation near the same ) **
- I want it to be a small class that way it's open for connection and closeness
- Teacher could get insight to students life by literally following them home instead of trying to get them to "open" up. Although that might be creepy, realize its just a movie.
- Students could follow teacher home and use his life against him. Work on his weaknesses etc. Again .. just an idea. In real life I understand that would be creepy/weird. **
- Public school - students will realize they're merely a number not a brain. High school isn't for learning, its about memorizing and applying.
- Teacher always making things seem better (always on trips or something.. showing them stuff that relates to them and applying it to their importance) ... making things better but clearly not the solution.
- SILENT FILMS ( always fun plus very exaggerated facial expressions make everyone's overall interpretation near the same ) **
- I want it to be a small class that way it's open for connection and closeness
- Teacher could get insight to students life by literally following them home instead of trying to get them to "open" up. Although that might be creepy, realize its just a movie.
- Students could follow teacher home and use his life against him. Work on his weaknesses etc. Again .. just an idea. In real life I understand that would be creepy/weird. **
- Public school - students will realize they're merely a number not a brain. High school isn't for learning, its about memorizing and applying.
Monday, March 15, 2010
44 - Big Expectations For School
Sociological Concepts:
I disagree with the formula's Institution's provide or so claimed by this site. A desire for love does not always become a desire to marry. My father, for one, loves affection but the idea of marriage never appealed to him. Though, he was most alone when he had no one to care for him (sort of like a mother figure.. who also provides sexual benefits). Next, my desire for happiness comes mostly from school. The better I do in my classes and the more I feel I understand the content, the happier I am because the happier I make my father. He never graduated high school so to see his daughter succeed is his most desired wish at this moment (especially because his older daughter never graduated). Granted, possessions makes everything just a little bit better but when you take into account all the poverty and starvation, etc- it's not the first thing that comes to mind when I think of "happy". My desire for an education though, does ultimately impends a desire for a good job. Of course I want a good job. I want to be able to travel when I get older and go out every night with friends and simply make good memories. School as an institution does provide me with that opportunity. As fore a desire for democracy - well I'm not huge on politics. I'm hoping that later on in life I'll become more involved (more specifically after I'm 18).
Liberal Arts Education:
So, from what I understand, it's not what you learn, its how you apply it to your everyday life. In general I don't really agree. I mean, is the reason for learning science so that we can analyze data and test hypothesis. I think generally the human mind is programmed to do just that all on its own without learning science. As children (without school), we analyze the situation and act on it. We test different methods such as crying and shouting for things we want or just simply behaving and being rewarded at the end. Granted I think school definitely sharpens those aspects but they don't "teach" us how to do them. However, specifically pertaining to art, I do think it helps us appreciate the "richness and endless diversity of human imagination". Speaking for myself, I've never appreciated art until school taught me that the beauty of art is that it can be perceived in so many different ways. It can tell stories, it can be a "mirror" which acts as a representation of whatever the art is on, it can be a "hammer" in which to offer change. Art never appealed to me before I knew I could understand it and I guess I should be thankful for school in allowing me to see that I can do just that.
Benefits Of Intellectual An Social Awakening:
This was my favorite article to read as it focuses on what I want to look more into about schools: teacher's passion for learning. So they say the curriculum is important but its the teachers drive to be the best teacher they can be that triggers the same osrt of feeling in students. I loved how they mentioned that the teacher, Ms. Kenny, observed no noise when students changed classrooms and that reminds me a lot about how noisy and active children naturally are and how school teaches us to obedient and listen to authority figures and not to identify ourselves as "animals" (loud and wild.) School does indeed teach the fundamentals by promoting no violence which I think is a great thing, but I do think kids need to find a way to express their emotions otherwise studies show it can lead to insanity (bottled up emotions). Also, parents promote the same thing at home (no violence) so it doesn't need to be that exaggerated in school.
“They were trying to replicate programs instead of trying to develop people.” < I think school needs to focus on developing people rather than teaching curriculum.
I disagree with the formula's Institution's provide or so claimed by this site. A desire for love does not always become a desire to marry. My father, for one, loves affection but the idea of marriage never appealed to him. Though, he was most alone when he had no one to care for him (sort of like a mother figure.. who also provides sexual benefits). Next, my desire for happiness comes mostly from school. The better I do in my classes and the more I feel I understand the content, the happier I am because the happier I make my father. He never graduated high school so to see his daughter succeed is his most desired wish at this moment (especially because his older daughter never graduated). Granted, possessions makes everything just a little bit better but when you take into account all the poverty and starvation, etc- it's not the first thing that comes to mind when I think of "happy". My desire for an education though, does ultimately impends a desire for a good job. Of course I want a good job. I want to be able to travel when I get older and go out every night with friends and simply make good memories. School as an institution does provide me with that opportunity. As fore a desire for democracy - well I'm not huge on politics. I'm hoping that later on in life I'll become more involved (more specifically after I'm 18).
Liberal Arts Education:
So, from what I understand, it's not what you learn, its how you apply it to your everyday life. In general I don't really agree. I mean, is the reason for learning science so that we can analyze data and test hypothesis. I think generally the human mind is programmed to do just that all on its own without learning science. As children (without school), we analyze the situation and act on it. We test different methods such as crying and shouting for things we want or just simply behaving and being rewarded at the end. Granted I think school definitely sharpens those aspects but they don't "teach" us how to do them. However, specifically pertaining to art, I do think it helps us appreciate the "richness and endless diversity of human imagination". Speaking for myself, I've never appreciated art until school taught me that the beauty of art is that it can be perceived in so many different ways. It can tell stories, it can be a "mirror" which acts as a representation of whatever the art is on, it can be a "hammer" in which to offer change. Art never appealed to me before I knew I could understand it and I guess I should be thankful for school in allowing me to see that I can do just that.
Benefits Of Intellectual An Social Awakening:
This was my favorite article to read as it focuses on what I want to look more into about schools: teacher's passion for learning. So they say the curriculum is important but its the teachers drive to be the best teacher they can be that triggers the same osrt of feeling in students. I loved how they mentioned that the teacher, Ms. Kenny, observed no noise when students changed classrooms and that reminds me a lot about how noisy and active children naturally are and how school teaches us to obedient and listen to authority figures and not to identify ourselves as "animals" (loud and wild.) School does indeed teach the fundamentals by promoting no violence which I think is a great thing, but I do think kids need to find a way to express their emotions otherwise studies show it can lead to insanity (bottled up emotions). Also, parents promote the same thing at home (no violence) so it doesn't need to be that exaggerated in school.
“They were trying to replicate programs instead of trying to develop people.” < I think school needs to focus on developing people rather than teaching curriculum.
Monday, March 1, 2010
HW 42 - Significance
I still don't know exactly what I'm going to be looking into but I know for a fact I'm highly interested in the whole teacher-student relationship and what can come of it. I'm still confused on what question(s) to ask that will lead me to solid/interesting information. If I had to ‘narrow’ it down, it would probably be the teachers affect on students and their overall school experience.
I feel like this question is important to me because as I look back at all my school memories, the best ones involved some amazing teachers. I remember being in 3rd grade and feeling so happy that my teacher cared for me so much. She’d always tell me how smart I was and how much potential I had and how ahead I would be if I’d just do my homework. She’d always know when something was wrong and find a way to make me feel better. She was definitely the first teacher I had that I realized learning was something I loved doing. She made me feel so happy to know the answers to problems and be able to tackle problems she gave us with ease. In 4th grade, I had a different teacher. I knew she didn’t care as much because she never really bothered with me. She left me to myself. I didn’t care as much for school and was always looking for a way to stay home. I guess I values having a connection with my teacher. I liked someone telling me I can do whatever I thought I couldn’t. After reading Tuesdays With Morrie, I sort of have this really big hope that in college I can become as close to my professor(s) as Mitch was to Morrie. I admire that relationship so much. The thing is, I can’t put my finger on why I do. I think maybe if I have a professor(s) that cares, then I’ll be that much more motivated to do my absolute best.
I don’t know much about what I want to do for the rest of my life or what I want to pursue, but I do know a couple things about what I enjoy most at this point in my life. As of right now it’s playing sports, learning, laughing, and relationships (with my friends, guys, teachers, advisers, etc). Because learning makes me feel so good about myself and happier in general, I know it really matters to me and plays a big role in my life. I think I might want to share this passion by actually becoming a teacher and showing students just how fulfilling the feeling of learning makes you feel. I think if I can do that (share my passion for learning - with or without becoming a teacher), I’ll be able to say that I lived a life well lived (at least to my standards).
I feel like this question is important to me because as I look back at all my school memories, the best ones involved some amazing teachers. I remember being in 3rd grade and feeling so happy that my teacher cared for me so much. She’d always tell me how smart I was and how much potential I had and how ahead I would be if I’d just do my homework. She’d always know when something was wrong and find a way to make me feel better. She was definitely the first teacher I had that I realized learning was something I loved doing. She made me feel so happy to know the answers to problems and be able to tackle problems she gave us with ease. In 4th grade, I had a different teacher. I knew she didn’t care as much because she never really bothered with me. She left me to myself. I didn’t care as much for school and was always looking for a way to stay home. I guess I values having a connection with my teacher. I liked someone telling me I can do whatever I thought I couldn’t. After reading Tuesdays With Morrie, I sort of have this really big hope that in college I can become as close to my professor(s) as Mitch was to Morrie. I admire that relationship so much. The thing is, I can’t put my finger on why I do. I think maybe if I have a professor(s) that cares, then I’ll be that much more motivated to do my absolute best.
I don’t know much about what I want to do for the rest of my life or what I want to pursue, but I do know a couple things about what I enjoy most at this point in my life. As of right now it’s playing sports, learning, laughing, and relationships (with my friends, guys, teachers, advisers, etc). Because learning makes me feel so good about myself and happier in general, I know it really matters to me and plays a big role in my life. I think I might want to share this passion by actually becoming a teacher and showing students just how fulfilling the feeling of learning makes you feel. I think if I can do that (share my passion for learning - with or without becoming a teacher), I’ll be able to say that I lived a life well lived (at least to my standards).
Monday, February 22, 2010
HW 41 - Initial Internet Research on Schooling: Edited
1)
Mariam. "Everybody Has The Right To Be Educated". Source. Education News, Special Education. January 7th, 2009.
This article argues that everyone has a right to an education despite physical ability, race, gender, etc. Students with physical, emotional, or mental "issues" are educated by 'special education teachers who are involved in the students’ behavioral, social, and academic development. Education doesn't discriminate and there's always an alternative for children if they need some sort of special attention.
This article is very short and easy to read. However, it provides no real depth to her insight. If she is arguing that education does not discriminate, she should probably include how the educational department holds different standards for different races, physical abilities, etc. I would argue that as discrimination itself. Also, the author defines 'everyone' being human beings and equal to god. Those two factors justify your right to an education (or so according to the article).
2)
Hasmik. "Education Is For Everyone". Source. Special Education. November 17th, 2008.
This article argues that education is the basis of our whole career and life itself. To be successful, we must pay attention to our education because only a well-educated, literate person can survive in this world. Everyone has the right to an education no matter your health or economic status because we are all equal and have the same rights.
This article is also very short and easy to read/follow. I found it as a follow-up link to the previous above article. I think, just as the last article, this one lacks solid reasoning. Hasmik seems to just say his ideas but he has no real evidence supporting why he thinks the way he does. Saying that education leads to success is so typical. Hasmik fails to mention that education doesn't always lead to success. Education can lead to an ‘okay livable lifestyle’ (not exactly the way you always dreamed of living but not a bad/hard way of living). He doesn't even define success. I guess this article is good if you want to start off by reading on very basic ideas/brainstorming.
3)
Horany, Elizabeth. "Women's Issues Then And Now". Source. Utexas. May 18th, 2002.
This web page talks about how equality was fought for from woman for so long. It argues that education as a stepping stone in gaining equality but it also mentions the inequality in expectations for woman and men to still be an issue. Education is a way to attain equal status in society and before that woman were seen as lower-class citizens who couldn’t vote/own property etc.
I like this source because it offers the history of woman in education, reasons for oppression, and its social relevance. It's a bit longer than the above two sources but it’s just as easy to understand. This source also gives quotes of lines that support their arguments such as what other people thought about woman in education (Queen Victoria specifically). I think I might want to refer back to this source if I continue in this direction of internet research/area (topic) of interest.
4)
Fırat Açıkgöz. "A Study On Teacher Characteristics And Their Effects On Students Attitudes". Source. The Reading Matrix Vol. 5, No. 2, September 2005.
This article is mainly about how the styles of teachers affect the students attitude and overall approach to school work. It mainly talks about how teachers choose to tackle certain things such as classroom management and the outcome/ how the students mainly react.
I thought this source was very informative about teachers and students and the interactions between the two especially because the article was made after conducting several interviews from the students and talking to the teachers. Although this article was helpful, it was taken in a Turkish mono-lingual setting and was done as an extension of earlier studies to provide feedback to Turkish teachers.
5)
William L. Saunders and June C. Rivers. "Cumulative and Residual Effects of Teachers On Future Student Academic Achievement". Source. University of Tennessee Value Added Research And Assessment Center. November 1996.
The portion of the article I focused in on explained how as teacher effectiveness increases, lower achieving students are the first to benefit.
Good article, easy to follow and read. This information was gathered through the TVAAS and specifically explains and pertains to the students of Tennessee. I like how this source breaks each step up (of how they got their information to how they analyzed it). I also like how they compared students scores in math, reading, language arts, science and social studies to the teachers style of teaching and then made further predictions based on the information that was gathered.
Additional Works Consulted:
The Right To Be Educated: Source 6
Education and Human Rights: Source 7
You Have To Be Educated To Be A Leader: Source 8
Teacher and Classroom Context Effects on Student Achievement: Source 9
How Large Are Teacher Effects?: Source 10
Mariam. "Everybody Has The Right To Be Educated". Source. Education News, Special Education. January 7th, 2009.
This article argues that everyone has a right to an education despite physical ability, race, gender, etc. Students with physical, emotional, or mental "issues" are educated by 'special education teachers who are involved in the students’ behavioral, social, and academic development. Education doesn't discriminate and there's always an alternative for children if they need some sort of special attention.
This article is very short and easy to read. However, it provides no real depth to her insight. If she is arguing that education does not discriminate, she should probably include how the educational department holds different standards for different races, physical abilities, etc. I would argue that as discrimination itself. Also, the author defines 'everyone' being human beings and equal to god. Those two factors justify your right to an education (or so according to the article).
2)
Hasmik. "Education Is For Everyone". Source. Special Education. November 17th, 2008.
This article argues that education is the basis of our whole career and life itself. To be successful, we must pay attention to our education because only a well-educated, literate person can survive in this world. Everyone has the right to an education no matter your health or economic status because we are all equal and have the same rights.
This article is also very short and easy to read/follow. I found it as a follow-up link to the previous above article. I think, just as the last article, this one lacks solid reasoning. Hasmik seems to just say his ideas but he has no real evidence supporting why he thinks the way he does. Saying that education leads to success is so typical. Hasmik fails to mention that education doesn't always lead to success. Education can lead to an ‘okay livable lifestyle’ (not exactly the way you always dreamed of living but not a bad/hard way of living). He doesn't even define success. I guess this article is good if you want to start off by reading on very basic ideas/brainstorming.
3)
Horany, Elizabeth. "Women's Issues Then And Now". Source. Utexas. May 18th, 2002.
This web page talks about how equality was fought for from woman for so long. It argues that education as a stepping stone in gaining equality but it also mentions the inequality in expectations for woman and men to still be an issue. Education is a way to attain equal status in society and before that woman were seen as lower-class citizens who couldn’t vote/own property etc.
I like this source because it offers the history of woman in education, reasons for oppression, and its social relevance. It's a bit longer than the above two sources but it’s just as easy to understand. This source also gives quotes of lines that support their arguments such as what other people thought about woman in education (Queen Victoria specifically). I think I might want to refer back to this source if I continue in this direction of internet research/area (topic) of interest.
4)
Fırat Açıkgöz. "A Study On Teacher Characteristics And Their Effects On Students Attitudes". Source. The Reading Matrix Vol. 5, No. 2, September 2005.
This article is mainly about how the styles of teachers affect the students attitude and overall approach to school work. It mainly talks about how teachers choose to tackle certain things such as classroom management and the outcome/ how the students mainly react.
I thought this source was very informative about teachers and students and the interactions between the two especially because the article was made after conducting several interviews from the students and talking to the teachers. Although this article was helpful, it was taken in a Turkish mono-lingual setting and was done as an extension of earlier studies to provide feedback to Turkish teachers.
5)
William L. Saunders and June C. Rivers. "Cumulative and Residual Effects of Teachers On Future Student Academic Achievement". Source. University of Tennessee Value Added Research And Assessment Center. November 1996.
The portion of the article I focused in on explained how as teacher effectiveness increases, lower achieving students are the first to benefit.
Good article, easy to follow and read. This information was gathered through the TVAAS and specifically explains and pertains to the students of Tennessee. I like how this source breaks each step up (of how they got their information to how they analyzed it). I also like how they compared students scores in math, reading, language arts, science and social studies to the teachers style of teaching and then made further predictions based on the information that was gathered.
Additional Works Consulted:
The Right To Be Educated: Source 6
Education and Human Rights: Source 7
You Have To Be Educated To Be A Leader: Source 8
Teacher and Classroom Context Effects on Student Achievement: Source 9
How Large Are Teacher Effects?: Source 10
Sunday, February 21, 2010
HW 40 - School Interviews and Synthesis
Part A:
In all of my interviews, I started off very basic by asking them to tell me about their experience as a student. From there, I sort of just asked follow up questions on the spot. I also listed their high schools and year of attendance because I realized that the setting plays a big role on their thoughts about school. I interviewed Jon (Hill) because I thought it was interesting to see his perspectives on the relationship (if any) between schooling in France vs. schooling here. My grandmother who made it to 4th grade only, my father who made it to 11th grade, his girlfriend who finished high school and college and became a teacher for elementary kids, and her son who currently attends high school. Everyone talked about their overall experience even if I asked questions that seemed to focus on just the ideas.
Notes:
Name, Age, School, Year of high school attendance
Adam, 17, Leadership and Public Service, 2006-10: School sucks, I hate it. We have tests and quizzes every other day. Homework every single day. No gym and the lunch is terrible. Teachers suck. They’re always yelling. Hate the rules – No chewing gum, no hats. They do it to try and make everything right. Their life sucks, take anger out on us. They have nothing better to do. Likes: Sports, school parties, dean (he’s ‘cool’), friends. Teachers barely help. Everyone thinks they give us an education but they don’t teach anything that ‘sticks’. Their teaching isn’t good enough. I would like for them to talk to me about what I can do to succeed. 30 kids to a classroom. They just want money. After schools done, my teachers are nowhere to be found. I think school makes my behavior worse. All the yelling makes me tense up. My old school (Tito Puente) was definitely better. Teachers were cool. Lunch was better. Big school. Big gym. I was a better person. I was better in sports.
Dad, 52, Seward Park, ~1973: School was fun. Great teachers. Great classmates. Teachers worked with you. Took time out for you, they cared. Classmates were funny and helpful. At the time, Vietnam was over and people were still talking about it. Made people closer – sort of like a family. Disliked the racism. Racist kids would beat up on one kid. Teachers mostly stood out of outside school issues. High school teachers played favoritism. Of course I wasn’t a favorite. With time education got better. There was no computer access. A lot slower. Todays school system is better – information at your fingertips. Before it was so much to do research. I stopped school because of the money I was making working with my father as a carpenter. I loved it though. I do wish I finished it. It helped me because it made me appreciate learning more. We didn’t have that many tests or quizzes. Never a lot of homework. More physical. Hands on.
Sally, 52, Mable Dean Bacon, 1973-77: Wonderful. All girls school. No distractions (no boys). Spent time with teachers. Wasn’t overcrowded. They cared. About 18 or so kids to a class. Teachers made it fun and interesting. We had to do and learn things ourselves. No computers. More research. Teachers made it so that we want to come back. I look at you guys today and you all hate school. I never liked math. They taught it well I just never liked it because I still couldn’t grasp everything. Afterschool my teacher worked with me one on one. I always wanted to learn. It made me want to further my education. Wasn’t about materials and who wore what. Everyone wanted to learn and that’s what they were there for. Once you got a degree, you knew you had a job, now it’s more about who you know. People with masters can’t find jobs. For teachers it wasn’t about money. They did more volunteering if anything. Less stressful before.
Grandma, 71, N/A, Would have been around 1946ish: I made it up to 4th grade. Don’t remember much. I learned how to read and write. I learned everything on my own (through experience and just growing up). Very poor. Spent days trading food. Learned how to cook by her mother. I think school is very important and I tried to get my kids to go to school to get a good job. School gives you education and opens opportunities. Maybe if I stayed in school who knows what I could have done with my life. Better off if I had gone to school. I married a man who supported me and our family. I never needed to work. My job was to cook and raise the children. I took care of the house. During the time I should have been in school, I was helping raise my baby sister.
Jon, 17, School of the Future/Lycee Jean Victor Poncelet, 2006-10: Being a student hasn't been anything monumental in my life. I'd describe myself as someone who's very curious and who enjoys learning but I'm in a bit of a catch 22. I like structure, and think that school should make disciplined students, but feel that too much discipline is bad but when given too much freedom, I slack off. I think there should be a healthy medium. In France, formalized education is very, very important. Students have a lot of difficulty adapting to a system that fosters a gap between students and professors. In France, the teacher is always right, and isn't committed to the student outside of their job descriptions: they get paid to teach, not to be life mentors. Relationships are very impersonal there. At sof however, it's almost the opposite. We call our teachers by their first names, we curse whenever we want, we lack respect so there needs to be a balance. I think that schooling now incorporates ideas that weren't considered as important before. Schools nowadays act as community centers, and teachers are called on to provide assistance to students well beyond the realms of simply "teaching". Teachers used to be considered authority figures, and were only there to do their job. Now, teachers become informal guidance counselors, and at younger and younger ages, students become informal with their elders but the ideas of discipline are being lost because everyone is becoming so much more informal so I think school systems need to backtrack a little bit in order to reinstall respect into the minds of the youth.
Part B:
One of the most important factors that can affect the whole outlook of school is how much the teacher cares. It means more to children if they’re enthusiastic about teaching. If they are willing to give up time after school or even work with you one on one you feel better, than you’re much more motivated. People generally don’t respond well to disappointment so if teachers cared about the students more often, students would feel pressured into not letting them down and striving for their best. They would also be much more likely to do homework at home resulting in preparation for the class and an overall higher understanding of the class work. Classmates are mainly on the side. They’re fun to be around and can make your school experience better if you make good friends but overall they’re nothing special. When teachers care, students care. Teachers who show that they’re only there for the money and who aren’t so much willing to help out enforce children to not care and do other things as well.
If school was based more on what children like (gym), and had better food, children would refer to school as a happier environment making it a place they like to come to and like to consider as a second home. If respect wasn’t such a big deal and people found a ‘healthy medium’ that both kids and teachers could agree on, then school would be much more of a likeable place. It’s simple things like being a teacher who cares, good food, more time to be physically active, and demanded less obedience, school would be a place kids would gladly wake up bright and early for.
In all of my interviews, I started off very basic by asking them to tell me about their experience as a student. From there, I sort of just asked follow up questions on the spot. I also listed their high schools and year of attendance because I realized that the setting plays a big role on their thoughts about school. I interviewed Jon (Hill) because I thought it was interesting to see his perspectives on the relationship (if any) between schooling in France vs. schooling here. My grandmother who made it to 4th grade only, my father who made it to 11th grade, his girlfriend who finished high school and college and became a teacher for elementary kids, and her son who currently attends high school. Everyone talked about their overall experience even if I asked questions that seemed to focus on just the ideas.
Notes:
Name, Age, School, Year of high school attendance
Adam, 17, Leadership and Public Service, 2006-10: School sucks, I hate it. We have tests and quizzes every other day. Homework every single day. No gym and the lunch is terrible. Teachers suck. They’re always yelling. Hate the rules – No chewing gum, no hats. They do it to try and make everything right. Their life sucks, take anger out on us. They have nothing better to do. Likes: Sports, school parties, dean (he’s ‘cool’), friends. Teachers barely help. Everyone thinks they give us an education but they don’t teach anything that ‘sticks’. Their teaching isn’t good enough. I would like for them to talk to me about what I can do to succeed. 30 kids to a classroom. They just want money. After schools done, my teachers are nowhere to be found. I think school makes my behavior worse. All the yelling makes me tense up. My old school (Tito Puente) was definitely better. Teachers were cool. Lunch was better. Big school. Big gym. I was a better person. I was better in sports.
Dad, 52, Seward Park, ~1973: School was fun. Great teachers. Great classmates. Teachers worked with you. Took time out for you, they cared. Classmates were funny and helpful. At the time, Vietnam was over and people were still talking about it. Made people closer – sort of like a family. Disliked the racism. Racist kids would beat up on one kid. Teachers mostly stood out of outside school issues. High school teachers played favoritism. Of course I wasn’t a favorite. With time education got better. There was no computer access. A lot slower. Todays school system is better – information at your fingertips. Before it was so much to do research. I stopped school because of the money I was making working with my father as a carpenter. I loved it though. I do wish I finished it. It helped me because it made me appreciate learning more. We didn’t have that many tests or quizzes. Never a lot of homework. More physical. Hands on.
Sally, 52, Mable Dean Bacon, 1973-77: Wonderful. All girls school. No distractions (no boys). Spent time with teachers. Wasn’t overcrowded. They cared. About 18 or so kids to a class. Teachers made it fun and interesting. We had to do and learn things ourselves. No computers. More research. Teachers made it so that we want to come back. I look at you guys today and you all hate school. I never liked math. They taught it well I just never liked it because I still couldn’t grasp everything. Afterschool my teacher worked with me one on one. I always wanted to learn. It made me want to further my education. Wasn’t about materials and who wore what. Everyone wanted to learn and that’s what they were there for. Once you got a degree, you knew you had a job, now it’s more about who you know. People with masters can’t find jobs. For teachers it wasn’t about money. They did more volunteering if anything. Less stressful before.
Grandma, 71, N/A, Would have been around 1946ish: I made it up to 4th grade. Don’t remember much. I learned how to read and write. I learned everything on my own (through experience and just growing up). Very poor. Spent days trading food. Learned how to cook by her mother. I think school is very important and I tried to get my kids to go to school to get a good job. School gives you education and opens opportunities. Maybe if I stayed in school who knows what I could have done with my life. Better off if I had gone to school. I married a man who supported me and our family. I never needed to work. My job was to cook and raise the children. I took care of the house. During the time I should have been in school, I was helping raise my baby sister.
Jon, 17, School of the Future/Lycee Jean Victor Poncelet, 2006-10: Being a student hasn't been anything monumental in my life. I'd describe myself as someone who's very curious and who enjoys learning but I'm in a bit of a catch 22. I like structure, and think that school should make disciplined students, but feel that too much discipline is bad but when given too much freedom, I slack off. I think there should be a healthy medium. In France, formalized education is very, very important. Students have a lot of difficulty adapting to a system that fosters a gap between students and professors. In France, the teacher is always right, and isn't committed to the student outside of their job descriptions: they get paid to teach, not to be life mentors. Relationships are very impersonal there. At sof however, it's almost the opposite. We call our teachers by their first names, we curse whenever we want, we lack respect so there needs to be a balance. I think that schooling now incorporates ideas that weren't considered as important before. Schools nowadays act as community centers, and teachers are called on to provide assistance to students well beyond the realms of simply "teaching". Teachers used to be considered authority figures, and were only there to do their job. Now, teachers become informal guidance counselors, and at younger and younger ages, students become informal with their elders but the ideas of discipline are being lost because everyone is becoming so much more informal so I think school systems need to backtrack a little bit in order to reinstall respect into the minds of the youth.
Part B:
One of the most important factors that can affect the whole outlook of school is how much the teacher cares. It means more to children if they’re enthusiastic about teaching. If they are willing to give up time after school or even work with you one on one you feel better, than you’re much more motivated. People generally don’t respond well to disappointment so if teachers cared about the students more often, students would feel pressured into not letting them down and striving for their best. They would also be much more likely to do homework at home resulting in preparation for the class and an overall higher understanding of the class work. Classmates are mainly on the side. They’re fun to be around and can make your school experience better if you make good friends but overall they’re nothing special. When teachers care, students care. Teachers who show that they’re only there for the money and who aren’t so much willing to help out enforce children to not care and do other things as well.
If school was based more on what children like (gym), and had better food, children would refer to school as a happier environment making it a place they like to come to and like to consider as a second home. If respect wasn’t such a big deal and people found a ‘healthy medium’ that both kids and teachers could agree on, then school would be much more of a likeable place. It’s simple things like being a teacher who cares, good food, more time to be physically active, and demanded less obedience, school would be a place kids would gladly wake up bright and early for.
Sunday, February 7, 2010
Art Project: Cool
Cool: A Silent Film from Esther Dionisio on Vimeo.
For my cool ‘art project’, I worked with my sister and Esther (two really creative people – good pick, I know).
I definitely think part of being cool is not only grabbing everyone’s attention while standing out, but being able to grab the attention that makes others want to be like you. In the video, there’s this lost soul (me) who is desperate for attention. I end up trying to change who I am to gain acceptance from my peers (mainly Esther) who doesn’t mind ‘helping’ me change. Also, like both Lauren and Esther stressed, this video is about trying not to lose touch with your own style (or at least the style you like), and character (who you are vs. who you’re trying to change yourself to become). *In general I think people are always going to change, but some people ‘act’ while others ‘become’. I don’t think people should do things they don’t want to for attention. I think people should think for themselves about what really matters to them and why.
I hope people realize just how much they dress like their ‘friends’ and that it’s not a coincidence. I also hope they realize that it’s not cool anymore. If you’re trying to stand out .. you should try dressing differently.
We started off with a few hours of planning. Then when we were ready to start filming, we realized we needed more people than we had this weekend. We thought a lot more and realized that we had so many ‘cool’ ideas for a video but not really a video that said anything about being cool. Then I started thinking about t.v and commercials and really wanted to do something like a commercial I saw a while back. In the commercial, it was some guy standing there and people were changing his clothing, making him do things like smoke, and even shaved his head bald. After a lot of quick changes, the guy stops them all and walks away. That’s what we tried to do. We also talked about how we wanted to show not tell .. so we didn’t want any talking in the video. So lovely Sandy suggested a silent film. And that’s how that came to be. We did a lot of filming, because Esther wanted more angles, and the whole disappearing thing came from an earlier idea of a film we thought we were going to do. We decided to include it anyway in this one for both special effects and so that people can perceive it any way they want to. I contributed ideas for the project and acted.
Making art has always been challenging for me. I’m not a very creative person. It’s never been my area of expertise. Do I think it’s cool? That all depends on what you’re defining cool as. If cool is fun and admirable and ‘standing out’, then yes this video is very cool. Why? Because it was so much fun to make this video – we had to do each part over and over again, and for a while Esther left the camera on record without telling us and thank god she didn’t put those parts in the ‘bloopers’- we did some silly things. We made friends with the guy at the front desk – and yes that was the first time we met him =D. Plus – this is very admirable. I mean I wish I had Esther’s editing talents. And I definitely think this video stands out… I mean come on – who else made a silent film?
Tuesday, January 19, 2010
HW 30
Emptiness can feel different to everyone. To some it might be an unsatisfying feeling with life (constantly looking for fulfillment- going out, buying things, altering your outer appearance, etc. Basically anything that’ll both keep and draw attention), to some it might be confusion you have with your own life map (Freud’s theory - dealing with and/or learning to identify with either of your parents which allows you to in a way create your own path based on what’s been offered), but to me, most popularly, it’s a disappointing feeling that there’s no real sense to our lives. We live to die, we want what we can’t have and don’t care for things we do have, the fact that no matter what we do or what happens the world does not care (“the gentle indifference of the world”), etc.
The first source I read was about Buddhists and the origin of dukkha (which means bad to the mouth). Primarily, this idea focuses on the suffering we feel in life (understanding it then learning to remove it), then realizing the termination of suffering and developing the path that leads to the stopping of suffering. This theory is (to me) merely a way to again take our attention off of the disappointing, unsatisfying feeling and confusion in your life and onto a more positive outlook. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying it doesn’t work – I’m sure it does, except I’m not convinced you can completely rid your mind and body of unwanted/unwelcoming feelings of dissatisfaction. To understand feelings so deeply and then try to stop them completely is like eating and trying to prevent your body from digesting. To me, impossible. *Maybe that was a weird metaphor.
Being ‘cool’ plays the same role as the Buddhists way of removing ‘unsavory’ feelings life brings to us. We’re trying to replace our current feelings with new ones – but the old feelings have been there for so long – to replace it we would have to push it aside and continuously find ways to program ourselves into thinking we can forget about them. For example, one aspect of cool is outer appearance. When we alter our outer appearance we’re trying to gain easy acceptance from others which gives us more time to not focus on ‘acting cool’. We can play ‘looking cool’ for as long as people think the well-dressed quiet (therefore mysterious) person is cool. Same as with Buddhists, they play that idea of removing those old feelings by trying to understand it, and then remove it while pushing aside the same inevitable feelings that are caused once again by the same things that made them want to understand it and remove it. Like a cycle. And with cool, you have to constantly change yourself but no matter how altered your appearance may be from your original self (the self that you were without changing your appearance countless times), we push aside the fact that we’re still that person and no matter how many times we try to change – we just fool ourselves into thinking we’re different. (Sorry if you can’t understand that. I’m having a hard time trying to convert my thoughts into comprehensible words).
The first source I read was about Buddhists and the origin of dukkha (which means bad to the mouth). Primarily, this idea focuses on the suffering we feel in life (understanding it then learning to remove it), then realizing the termination of suffering and developing the path that leads to the stopping of suffering. This theory is (to me) merely a way to again take our attention off of the disappointing, unsatisfying feeling and confusion in your life and onto a more positive outlook. Don’t get me wrong, I’m not saying it doesn’t work – I’m sure it does, except I’m not convinced you can completely rid your mind and body of unwanted/unwelcoming feelings of dissatisfaction. To understand feelings so deeply and then try to stop them completely is like eating and trying to prevent your body from digesting. To me, impossible. *Maybe that was a weird metaphor.
Being ‘cool’ plays the same role as the Buddhists way of removing ‘unsavory’ feelings life brings to us. We’re trying to replace our current feelings with new ones – but the old feelings have been there for so long – to replace it we would have to push it aside and continuously find ways to program ourselves into thinking we can forget about them. For example, one aspect of cool is outer appearance. When we alter our outer appearance we’re trying to gain easy acceptance from others which gives us more time to not focus on ‘acting cool’. We can play ‘looking cool’ for as long as people think the well-dressed quiet (therefore mysterious) person is cool. Same as with Buddhists, they play that idea of removing those old feelings by trying to understand it, and then remove it while pushing aside the same inevitable feelings that are caused once again by the same things that made them want to understand it and remove it. Like a cycle. And with cool, you have to constantly change yourself but no matter how altered your appearance may be from your original self (the self that you were without changing your appearance countless times), we push aside the fact that we’re still that person and no matter how many times we try to change – we just fool ourselves into thinking we’re different. (Sorry if you can’t understand that. I’m having a hard time trying to convert my thoughts into comprehensible words).
Monday, November 30, 2009
HW 21 - Art Project




I feel my art is a mirror in which to show people exactly what is happening to us as we are completely immersed into these digital representational devices. This is only so because I am not offering any solution to our issue. I am not showing what we can do to change. I am merely showing people what is happening as they are immersed into D.R.D’s on the train. Because my ‘art’ does not offer a solution or approach to change, I do not believe it to be a ‘hammer’.
First I want to begin explaining my art a bit better or at least the way I meant for others to see it (probably a bad idea since artists don’t really do this because the whole point of art is perspective but whatever). First I took a picture of a man on the train who was completely into his portable d.v.d player. He ended up missing his stop because when he looked up 10 minutes later, he said ‘shit’, closed his d.v.d player quickly and was very fidgety until the train made the next stop. I realized this guy must have been so into what he was doing that he was completely out of tune with where he was. This is where my second picture comes in. I took him out of his surroundings just as he so unconsciously did so to himself. In the third picture, I drew a man on the subway. This man was completely out of tune with who he was. He is so into what he is doing that he has no awareness that he’s even there at the moment. I drew this by taking himself out of the picture and outlining only his body. To sort of portray how he has no solid idea of his existence at that moment. The last picture shows the same as the third one. This woman is completely immersed that her mind is full of nothing but what she’s doing. I tried to do so by sort of allowing her soul to drift. Bad job probably because I’m really not creative or artistic. My art makes me think of both the ideas of disembodiment and displacement, which were the two main things I was trying to show. I think if people really understood the concept of my art, then it could really show how we can completely be out of touch with our surroundings and ourselves.
I think the most interesting aspect of making my art was noticing all of these people who have no idea that others are actually around them and can know that they are in a train but slowly lose grasp of that as they begin to familiarize themselves with things that make them comfortable and immerse themselves with those things (D.R.D’s). I saw better examples but it was hard to take pictures of them because I was scared they would notice and I didn’t feel like asking. The last two were taken off the internet and edited.
Thursday, November 5, 2009
HW 15 - ABCDEF 3 - Treasure Hunting
Comment to Rachel:
Rachel,
We have slightly different takes on Johnson’s perspective which made this post more enjoyable to read. It’s much more interesting to read about a new point of view rather than reading about someone who’s arguing the same thing as you are bringing up the same points.
Your main ideas were about how you agree with Johnson – video games stimulate our brain, and help us to design goals in order to further succeed in the game. You believe that games bring an urge to achieve the final goal and people will go to many lengths to do so. For TV, you agree with Johnson that some shows allow you to completely put yourself in their shoes and analyze what’s going on by putting previous pieces together. You also think that Johnson doesn’t quite give enough cons to technology to take a side but his offer of a fresh new perspective helps you become a bit more equipped to make a final judgment. You think people always focus on the corrupting digitalization brings to our minds rather than the developing it allows us to do. Lastly, you believe Johnson focus’ on videogames and television while Anderson focuses on the feed that can most currently represent a cell phone or computer.
I notice you and Charles seem to think Johnson plays sort of a devil’s advocate. You both think that because it’s so common for people to believe technology is bad for you – Johnson is going against everyone and helping them see the opposite point of view by offering the good that comes from heavy gaming, couch potatoes, etc. I agree except I failed to mention him actually being a devil’s advocate. I think Johnson does a good job at stepping outside his comfort zone – where he believes books are the better choice – and helping others see that these devices really aren’t all that bad for us. I also noticed how although you didn’t say it – you sort of implied the sense of disembodiment that comes along with developing different mental skills while watching television or playing videogames. In order to increase our skills using these devices, we must lose sense of who we are and where we are to become fully immersed and then practice the skills they allow us to practice in doing so.
I think you could’ve talked about the relationship between Feed and Johnson’s beliefs. You mention the obvious which is that Anderson doesn’t focus on games and televisions but rather the harm it does to people and society but doesn’t Anderson bring up some points about how ‘out of the loop’ you can be without the feed in the book, and how it’s a sad thing but now a days it’s becoming more and more of a necessity to keep up with everyone else. I also think you were very general with what you were writing and I think it probably would have been a good idea to focus more on certain aspects of what Johnson was saying and really write a response as to WHY you agree instead of just agreeing or WHY you disagree... etc.
In your post you sort of imply that people have to pick a side on this topic. I’m wondering what is so crucial about picking a side. I see where Johnson is coming from but I wouldn’t say I’m on a side. I sort of just think now – a little bit of both is pretty good for you – or would you consider being in the middle a side? Your post also makes me think about if watching TV and playing video games makes a big difference in the way people live their life – like for instance are readers really much more successful? (I’m defining successful meaning they make more of a living because of their well education and reading skills).
Well, next time I think you should challenge yourself and read the longer excerpt because I’m sure it’ll be just as easy to understand and pick at and it’ll give you more evidence to back up your own ideas. Good job though,
Comment to Amanda:
Amanda,
My favorite line: “We all know that computers act as a barrier and block our true feelings/emotions from being easily determined.” I really like the way it sounds and I agree with the point you make. It brings me back to thinking about how our computers are our identity masks – almost like a shield hiding who we really are but giving us the freedom to be whoever we want. Although this is indeed a reoccurring idea – I still agree with it.
Let’s see. You believe feed is an exaggerated world of the one we currently live in. You also think that we are approaching a complete immersion into digital technology just as the book Feed portrays. You think that having all this technology allows people to become lazy and incompetent and that losing digital exposure causes us to feel lost and even confused. You believe that we don’t really know what to do with ourselves without it. You also think that although we all know the affect is negative – we are still addicted. You believe we like hiding from our emotions through technology and that Feed is pretty much like a mirror for our society.
I like the point you make about how we have no control over our facial expressions and without technology we’d sort of be all over the place. We would have no control because we wouldn’t have much practice in doing so due to the fact that we’re always involved with D.R.D’s. I also think your ideas are those of the majority – D.R.D’s are affecting us in a negative way. Now that we’ve read ‘Everything Bad Is Good for You’, how do you think it affects your opinion, if at all? I say this because Steve Johnson argues that TV and Videogames help us practice and develop mental skills – both the ones used while reading books and ones that are just as important.
I think in the end it sounds sort of confusing when you say ‘we have to judge ourselves before judging the book because judging the book is judging ourselves’. Maybe you should try revising that to something like – By using this book as a mirror of who we are and how we interact with D.R.S’s we can judge ourselves by merely judging the book and hopefully finding new solutions or idea where we can start to help us away from the sickening addiction. Also I think in order to have stronger arguments; you can relate your ideas of feed (2nd to last paragraph) with our life. Something like – Just as the feed pays attention to the person’s conversations, likes and dislikes – if you were to research items on the internet, they usually provide links with related items or items people have also looked at who have looked at that item, etc.
Your post makes me think about what exactly feels so comfortable and so easy about texting them rather than talking to them face to face. I’m not trying to hide my emotions – I think I just have a harder time showing them in person in fear of rejection. Sometimes I just get shy. I can feel so strongly about something or someone – tell them or show it through text or online but then in person – I freeze up. I’m a t a loss of words. I want to say everything as easily as I did through text but somehow it just never comes out that way. This makes me realize how much of a convenience D.R.D’s are for me. How much I rely on them and addicted to them I am. I think maybe people are scared of unfamiliar feelings and therefore they stick to what they are used to – technology..
Anyway, I liked your post. You bring up some good points. Keep up the work – and lets work together on catching up with the rest of the assignments
Rachel,
We have slightly different takes on Johnson’s perspective which made this post more enjoyable to read. It’s much more interesting to read about a new point of view rather than reading about someone who’s arguing the same thing as you are bringing up the same points.
Your main ideas were about how you agree with Johnson – video games stimulate our brain, and help us to design goals in order to further succeed in the game. You believe that games bring an urge to achieve the final goal and people will go to many lengths to do so. For TV, you agree with Johnson that some shows allow you to completely put yourself in their shoes and analyze what’s going on by putting previous pieces together. You also think that Johnson doesn’t quite give enough cons to technology to take a side but his offer of a fresh new perspective helps you become a bit more equipped to make a final judgment. You think people always focus on the corrupting digitalization brings to our minds rather than the developing it allows us to do. Lastly, you believe Johnson focus’ on videogames and television while Anderson focuses on the feed that can most currently represent a cell phone or computer.
I notice you and Charles seem to think Johnson plays sort of a devil’s advocate. You both think that because it’s so common for people to believe technology is bad for you – Johnson is going against everyone and helping them see the opposite point of view by offering the good that comes from heavy gaming, couch potatoes, etc. I agree except I failed to mention him actually being a devil’s advocate. I think Johnson does a good job at stepping outside his comfort zone – where he believes books are the better choice – and helping others see that these devices really aren’t all that bad for us. I also noticed how although you didn’t say it – you sort of implied the sense of disembodiment that comes along with developing different mental skills while watching television or playing videogames. In order to increase our skills using these devices, we must lose sense of who we are and where we are to become fully immersed and then practice the skills they allow us to practice in doing so.
I think you could’ve talked about the relationship between Feed and Johnson’s beliefs. You mention the obvious which is that Anderson doesn’t focus on games and televisions but rather the harm it does to people and society but doesn’t Anderson bring up some points about how ‘out of the loop’ you can be without the feed in the book, and how it’s a sad thing but now a days it’s becoming more and more of a necessity to keep up with everyone else. I also think you were very general with what you were writing and I think it probably would have been a good idea to focus more on certain aspects of what Johnson was saying and really write a response as to WHY you agree instead of just agreeing or WHY you disagree... etc.
In your post you sort of imply that people have to pick a side on this topic. I’m wondering what is so crucial about picking a side. I see where Johnson is coming from but I wouldn’t say I’m on a side. I sort of just think now – a little bit of both is pretty good for you – or would you consider being in the middle a side? Your post also makes me think about if watching TV and playing video games makes a big difference in the way people live their life – like for instance are readers really much more successful? (I’m defining successful meaning they make more of a living because of their well education and reading skills).
Well, next time I think you should challenge yourself and read the longer excerpt because I’m sure it’ll be just as easy to understand and pick at and it’ll give you more evidence to back up your own ideas. Good job though,
Comment to Amanda:
Amanda,
My favorite line: “We all know that computers act as a barrier and block our true feelings/emotions from being easily determined.” I really like the way it sounds and I agree with the point you make. It brings me back to thinking about how our computers are our identity masks – almost like a shield hiding who we really are but giving us the freedom to be whoever we want. Although this is indeed a reoccurring idea – I still agree with it.
Let’s see. You believe feed is an exaggerated world of the one we currently live in. You also think that we are approaching a complete immersion into digital technology just as the book Feed portrays. You think that having all this technology allows people to become lazy and incompetent and that losing digital exposure causes us to feel lost and even confused. You believe that we don’t really know what to do with ourselves without it. You also think that although we all know the affect is negative – we are still addicted. You believe we like hiding from our emotions through technology and that Feed is pretty much like a mirror for our society.
I like the point you make about how we have no control over our facial expressions and without technology we’d sort of be all over the place. We would have no control because we wouldn’t have much practice in doing so due to the fact that we’re always involved with D.R.D’s. I also think your ideas are those of the majority – D.R.D’s are affecting us in a negative way. Now that we’ve read ‘Everything Bad Is Good for You’, how do you think it affects your opinion, if at all? I say this because Steve Johnson argues that TV and Videogames help us practice and develop mental skills – both the ones used while reading books and ones that are just as important.
I think in the end it sounds sort of confusing when you say ‘we have to judge ourselves before judging the book because judging the book is judging ourselves’. Maybe you should try revising that to something like – By using this book as a mirror of who we are and how we interact with D.R.S’s we can judge ourselves by merely judging the book and hopefully finding new solutions or idea where we can start to help us away from the sickening addiction. Also I think in order to have stronger arguments; you can relate your ideas of feed (2nd to last paragraph) with our life. Something like – Just as the feed pays attention to the person’s conversations, likes and dislikes – if you were to research items on the internet, they usually provide links with related items or items people have also looked at who have looked at that item, etc.
Your post makes me think about what exactly feels so comfortable and so easy about texting them rather than talking to them face to face. I’m not trying to hide my emotions – I think I just have a harder time showing them in person in fear of rejection. Sometimes I just get shy. I can feel so strongly about something or someone – tell them or show it through text or online but then in person – I freeze up. I’m a t a loss of words. I want to say everything as easily as I did through text but somehow it just never comes out that way. This makes me realize how much of a convenience D.R.D’s are for me. How much I rely on them and addicted to them I am. I think maybe people are scared of unfamiliar feelings and therefore they stick to what they are used to – technology..
Anyway, I liked your post. You bring up some good points. Keep up the work – and lets work together on catching up with the rest of the assignments
HW 14 - Second Text
In ‘Everything Bad Is Good for You’, the author Steven Johnson mainly argues that both television and games are increasingly developing the mental skills practiced while reading books and are even helping develop other mental skills not practices while reading books. In this way, television and videogames really aren’t that bad for you. Although he makes this point, he still makes it clear that he strongly believes in the practice of reading books because of many different ideas which include learning how to create ‘entire worlds’ while reading. He mentions how the growth of games and especially aspects of television (following story lines and filling in missing information to come up with a conclusion/solution to answer both questions – what is going on now and how will it all turn out) compared to earlier times and how everything is much more complex which is why the skills we practice while doing those activities are becoming more and more developed. Another argument he makes about the gaming industry is that it pulls in more money than Hollywood so now, not only are they helping increasing your skills but they are becoming more and more popular.
I think Johnson did a really good job at viewing a different perspective by arguing against his own. I thought it was very effective to imagine an ‘alternate’ world – one being where games came before reading. Also Johnson made a very valid point in the beginning when he talks about how adults are being more and more absorbed in the same kind of entertainment as children, which goes to show how much of digitalization affects everyone and not just our (the child’s) generation. I think he mainly focuses on the ups of reading while he mentions both the ups and downs about television and games. Sure he mentions less than a couple of bad things such as how reading sort of ‘stigmatizes’ people with dyslexia – a condition revealed only after reading came along but he mostly just talks of what benefits reading has. I think he should’ve talked more about the downs to reading like he has with videogames and TV to have a more accurate argument about why we should agree with him and choose reading books over videogames and TV.
Johnson talks about people who read compared to people who don’t read are much more active and are more likely to visit museums etc, but then he mentions how people who are heavy gamers show more improved skills than non-gamers (both the same skills that reading helps develop and other skills that are just as important). Johnson brings up a lot of point regarding how tv, games, and books all affect us and from my comprehension of his writing – I sort of think it’s a better idea to have children doing both rather than choosing one. If both help develop skills – why not do both. In the future I imagine the industry to become a lot more complex like it continuously has over the past 30 years – which gives good reason to allow the future children to practice both being digitalized and reading.
Let’s go back to this alternate world. I want to take it into consideration that games allow full sensory and more cortices while books only use a small part of our brain to process the language, imagine it, and follow the story line. Games are another way of becoming more social and help us to build and explore worlds with each other. Books sort of support this idea of being anti-social – you’re supposed to read by yourself, alone, and in a quiet environment. Children are supposed to be active so I also think games are a more approachable and realistically better option for children rather than reading books. I think when the child develops into an early adult – is when books should be provided for them to practice decoding and developing the complexity of argument, storytelling, and stretching of imagination. In this way after sharing the experience with someone else who has read the same thing – they can continue practicing being social and learn how to connect better with a person through this same shared experience. I agree sort of – I like having this shared experience with people about books I’ve read and knowing that they’ve probably felt very similar feelings because of similar reactions to the same experience, but I also like sort of making my own journey in a videogame and knowing that everyone else isn’t looking at the same screen while doing the same exact thing as I am. I agree with Johnson how people could sort of see how books teach us to feel powerless because we can’t do anything to control it while videogames teach us how to be leaders and make our own paths. Yes there are some bad qualities to video games that promote violence and aggression as a response to conflict but if we had more civilized video-games, we could easily take that factor out.
Televisions storylines, their increasing use of multithreading and our ability to put things together have been increasing since past times. The example he uses in his book is relating Dragnet to some old improves shows such as Hill Street Blues and our current TV shows such as ER, 24, Lost, etc. Since Dragnet, TV has become much more complex and Johnson shows so by providing date tables of threads you have to follow to make sense of the whole storyline. The data tables from more recent times are shown as more intricate than older television shows which supports his arguments for how television is helping us to develop more skills. I think if people were to stop and look at this information, we’d see just how much TV and videogames have changed and practically evolved and are indeed much more useful, helpful and maybe even crucial to us in developing different kinds of mental skills. Compared to back then – I think the argument stands stronger that in past times when digitalization was much simpler, reading would be a better option. Now that it’s grown – it’s probably smarter to do both.
Feed mostly talks about the benefits of having it. Sure, while reading you pick up on how bad their immersion into the feed is but for the most part all they’re doing is talking of benefits while only explaining maybe 2 or 3 alternatives (hacker, violet and her father). You see how digitalization has affected them in a way where their whole lives revolve around it and that because of becoming fully absorbed into their feed, when it’s gone – they all feel this sense of solitude. They all sort of notice how much they’re afraid of that because they’ve gotten so used to having the feed with them 24/7 and now that it’s gone – they realize they have no one but their ignorant selves and begin to realize how unintelligent we are and how we’ve taken knowledge and education for granted. In EBIG4U, it focuses more on the developing of these skills that can come from many different aspects of technology. Anderson is focusing more on how messed up we’ve become with this new technology and Johnson sort of contradicts it when he talks of the developing that comes from these things.
I think Johnson did a really good job at viewing a different perspective by arguing against his own. I thought it was very effective to imagine an ‘alternate’ world – one being where games came before reading. Also Johnson made a very valid point in the beginning when he talks about how adults are being more and more absorbed in the same kind of entertainment as children, which goes to show how much of digitalization affects everyone and not just our (the child’s) generation. I think he mainly focuses on the ups of reading while he mentions both the ups and downs about television and games. Sure he mentions less than a couple of bad things such as how reading sort of ‘stigmatizes’ people with dyslexia – a condition revealed only after reading came along but he mostly just talks of what benefits reading has. I think he should’ve talked more about the downs to reading like he has with videogames and TV to have a more accurate argument about why we should agree with him and choose reading books over videogames and TV.
Johnson talks about people who read compared to people who don’t read are much more active and are more likely to visit museums etc, but then he mentions how people who are heavy gamers show more improved skills than non-gamers (both the same skills that reading helps develop and other skills that are just as important). Johnson brings up a lot of point regarding how tv, games, and books all affect us and from my comprehension of his writing – I sort of think it’s a better idea to have children doing both rather than choosing one. If both help develop skills – why not do both. In the future I imagine the industry to become a lot more complex like it continuously has over the past 30 years – which gives good reason to allow the future children to practice both being digitalized and reading.
Let’s go back to this alternate world. I want to take it into consideration that games allow full sensory and more cortices while books only use a small part of our brain to process the language, imagine it, and follow the story line. Games are another way of becoming more social and help us to build and explore worlds with each other. Books sort of support this idea of being anti-social – you’re supposed to read by yourself, alone, and in a quiet environment. Children are supposed to be active so I also think games are a more approachable and realistically better option for children rather than reading books. I think when the child develops into an early adult – is when books should be provided for them to practice decoding and developing the complexity of argument, storytelling, and stretching of imagination. In this way after sharing the experience with someone else who has read the same thing – they can continue practicing being social and learn how to connect better with a person through this same shared experience. I agree sort of – I like having this shared experience with people about books I’ve read and knowing that they’ve probably felt very similar feelings because of similar reactions to the same experience, but I also like sort of making my own journey in a videogame and knowing that everyone else isn’t looking at the same screen while doing the same exact thing as I am. I agree with Johnson how people could sort of see how books teach us to feel powerless because we can’t do anything to control it while videogames teach us how to be leaders and make our own paths. Yes there are some bad qualities to video games that promote violence and aggression as a response to conflict but if we had more civilized video-games, we could easily take that factor out.
Televisions storylines, their increasing use of multithreading and our ability to put things together have been increasing since past times. The example he uses in his book is relating Dragnet to some old improves shows such as Hill Street Blues and our current TV shows such as ER, 24, Lost, etc. Since Dragnet, TV has become much more complex and Johnson shows so by providing date tables of threads you have to follow to make sense of the whole storyline. The data tables from more recent times are shown as more intricate than older television shows which supports his arguments for how television is helping us to develop more skills. I think if people were to stop and look at this information, we’d see just how much TV and videogames have changed and practically evolved and are indeed much more useful, helpful and maybe even crucial to us in developing different kinds of mental skills. Compared to back then – I think the argument stands stronger that in past times when digitalization was much simpler, reading would be a better option. Now that it’s grown – it’s probably smarter to do both.
Feed mostly talks about the benefits of having it. Sure, while reading you pick up on how bad their immersion into the feed is but for the most part all they’re doing is talking of benefits while only explaining maybe 2 or 3 alternatives (hacker, violet and her father). You see how digitalization has affected them in a way where their whole lives revolve around it and that because of becoming fully absorbed into their feed, when it’s gone – they all feel this sense of solitude. They all sort of notice how much they’re afraid of that because they’ve gotten so used to having the feed with them 24/7 and now that it’s gone – they realize they have no one but their ignorant selves and begin to realize how unintelligent we are and how we’ve taken knowledge and education for granted. In EBIG4U, it focuses more on the developing of these skills that can come from many different aspects of technology. Anderson is focusing more on how messed up we’ve become with this new technology and Johnson sort of contradicts it when he talks of the developing that comes from these things.
Tuesday, October 20, 2009
HW 13- FEED B
What killed me the most was that depressing feeling I felt after I finished reading Feed. Everyone in that society (with the exception of Violet and her father) is so stupid and ignorant- so consumed by the corporations – it’s pathetic. Then I reminded myself of how this is supposed to be an allegory for our current lifestyle. I feel so stupid. If this is how we look then I think I am ready to change. I don’t find enjoyment in most D.R.D’s to completely keep me immersed and I think it’s because of this course. I mean I already knew people are (including myself) are so addicted to these devices but it was never something I thought twice about.
In the beginning Titus is just like all of his other friends- just trying to fit in and have fun. They don’t really care about what the Feed can do to them (negatively) but rather what the Feed offers them. Sounds all too familiar. Before Andy’s class you could say I was just like Titus and his friends (not to that extreme). I never thought about what these digital representational devices did to me – I only thought about what good I think they do for me. Throughout the book Titus becomes more self-aware. Because of Violet, he begins to see all the damage (involving intelligence and self- awareness) the Feed causes people. Of course being that ignorance really is bliss – he never realized just how depressing it is to find out things really aren’t the way he sees them. Just as Titus – once I was exposed to this sad truth, I too became depressed. I’ve always known I was stupid but reading this book just made me realize that I’m a lot dumber than I think. It also made me realize just how much time I’ve wasted by artificially socializing with people through technology. Instead of gaining anything – with all this time wasted - I’ve lost so much. I’ve never really used my brain to think and develop new ideas – I just sort of let things do the thinking for me or did what was natural or what was expected. It really is disappointing.
Bert Brecht supposedly said that, "Art is not a Mirror with which to reflect the World. It is a Hammer with which to shape it." Because Feed merely reflected our own society and didn’t offer any real solutions for how to change except the obvious – deny the feed, I feel it can be most looked upon as a Mirror. I don’t think it’s a Hammer because Feed didn’t do shaping/changing. I think the purpose of the book was meant for change but the work itself made us step outside of our bubbles and really take a look inside. But this is my personal opinion with all art – always showing us how things are from the outer perspective but not really offering any solutions. It’s up to the reader to decide what to do with the knowledge.
If I had a choice I’d rather my work be a mirror too – for I believe that someone has to know the problem thoroughly, see it from different angles – to then attack and find a way to go about changing the problem. If my work was hammer – I think people would look at it, like it, but not really think twice about it – just as we do with all other things. Showing me a picture of how things could be rather than showing me a picture of how things are now would do nothing. You don’t go offering a solution to a problem unknown – you can’t fix what you don’t know is broken.
I think the book was meant for young adults because the problem is mainly with us. To adults –it would only support what they think about how D.R.D’s have really taken full control over us whereas to young adults – it shows us how we look from an outer perspective making us want to change (well hopefully). I honestly think the book was successful in reflecting our society but only because you made us analyze it and realize how it is an allegory for our current lifestyles. If no one makes you think about a book – most times (young adults specifically) read it and don’t put any thoughtful thinking into it- but rather just move on instead.
In the beginning Titus is just like all of his other friends- just trying to fit in and have fun. They don’t really care about what the Feed can do to them (negatively) but rather what the Feed offers them. Sounds all too familiar. Before Andy’s class you could say I was just like Titus and his friends (not to that extreme). I never thought about what these digital representational devices did to me – I only thought about what good I think they do for me. Throughout the book Titus becomes more self-aware. Because of Violet, he begins to see all the damage (involving intelligence and self- awareness) the Feed causes people. Of course being that ignorance really is bliss – he never realized just how depressing it is to find out things really aren’t the way he sees them. Just as Titus – once I was exposed to this sad truth, I too became depressed. I’ve always known I was stupid but reading this book just made me realize that I’m a lot dumber than I think. It also made me realize just how much time I’ve wasted by artificially socializing with people through technology. Instead of gaining anything – with all this time wasted - I’ve lost so much. I’ve never really used my brain to think and develop new ideas – I just sort of let things do the thinking for me or did what was natural or what was expected. It really is disappointing.
Bert Brecht supposedly said that, "Art is not a Mirror with which to reflect the World. It is a Hammer with which to shape it." Because Feed merely reflected our own society and didn’t offer any real solutions for how to change except the obvious – deny the feed, I feel it can be most looked upon as a Mirror. I don’t think it’s a Hammer because Feed didn’t do shaping/changing. I think the purpose of the book was meant for change but the work itself made us step outside of our bubbles and really take a look inside. But this is my personal opinion with all art – always showing us how things are from the outer perspective but not really offering any solutions. It’s up to the reader to decide what to do with the knowledge.
If I had a choice I’d rather my work be a mirror too – for I believe that someone has to know the problem thoroughly, see it from different angles – to then attack and find a way to go about changing the problem. If my work was hammer – I think people would look at it, like it, but not really think twice about it – just as we do with all other things. Showing me a picture of how things could be rather than showing me a picture of how things are now would do nothing. You don’t go offering a solution to a problem unknown – you can’t fix what you don’t know is broken.
I think the book was meant for young adults because the problem is mainly with us. To adults –it would only support what they think about how D.R.D’s have really taken full control over us whereas to young adults – it shows us how we look from an outer perspective making us want to change (well hopefully). I honestly think the book was successful in reflecting our society but only because you made us analyze it and realize how it is an allegory for our current lifestyles. If no one makes you think about a book – most times (young adults specifically) read it and don’t put any thoughtful thinking into it- but rather just move on instead.
Sunday, October 18, 2009
HW 12 - FEED A
I don’t think Feed necessarily misses the point but at the same time I think the book fails to really emphasize just how much not having the feed can affect you too. In a world that is completely taken over by technology – you are missing out on different sources of information and it will become much harder to connect to people as they are used to – as everyone else does. Now you may not think that it’s a bad thing but you have to think about situations like when Violets father was at the interview and the people interviewing him tried to chat him through the feed and he didn’t have it – they couldn’t take him seriously – he wasn’t up to date and was unable to connect with them on their level therefore he missed out on an opportunity. Things like that happen all the time. If you don’t have a cell-phone or email address etc, you miss out on many opportunities. In this world to stay connected you have to have at the very least an email address so that people can still get in contact with you – update you with new information, etc.
I guess I kind of see the parallels between Feed and our modern day teenage lives but in general I still feel Feed is way more exaggerated. Like the whole idea of the nice neighborhoods that pretty much can make the sun come and go whenever they want vs. poor neighborhoods that all share their uncontrolled days and nights. I feel like that might be a metaphor for how much easier life is for people who have money and how hard and ‘unexpected’ it is for people who don’t. How some things that don’t even matter to people who are well off, have a more valuable importance to those who are less fortunate. Or that’s probably not even the parallel for it – I don’t know.
Also the amount of marketing is ridiculous in the book. Anytime you think of something – you receive an advertisement for it, other things related to it or other items people look at who have previously looked at that item. The same thing goes for our society. Although we don’t have chips in our brains, we see advertisements everywhere we go – on billboards, transportation mobiles, cellphones, trains, tv, our computers, in music, on clothing, jewelry, etc. The feed is all around us and even on us.
I thought it was kind of ridiculous how in the book, they were all saying Coke a whole bunch of times to get free supplies thinking they were cheating the whole deal when really they just fell completely into it. It’s like now-a-days when people refer other people to things such as clubs of some sort they get discounts and so on so they keep telling more people thinking they’re benefitting themselves when really they’re only the companies’ source of making more money.
The artificial air factory was quite bizarre to me. I mean – the whole idea of getting rid of trees because of artificial air factories – god that’s scary. But I kind of see the metaphor with like libraries and how pretty soon no one’s really going to need them because we have all these other sources of information – I mean you can even find whole books online. And even movie theatres. One of your very few sources of watching movies was at the theatre – now you can go to blockbuster, order it from Netflix, see it on your computer, see it on your phone, and see it on your iPod. I mean nothing’s the same. We’re taking these interesting and entertaining ideas and making them super artificial and killing it by over-doing it. I’d like to one day go see a drive in movie – like how they used to do a long time ago. I’m sure they still have them I just don’t know where.
All the information they’ll ever need is sitting in their brains feed with extremely easy access. Like computers. We don’t even have to go to libraries or read through books to study – we can find online essays, go to sparknotes.com, dictionary.com, Wikipedia, etc. Everything is at the tip of our fingers. This reminds me of the movie Wall-e. In the movie, earth is no longer live-able so all humans live on this spaceship and you see them on chairs that move around so they don’t have to walk and something like feeds as a hologram right in front of them. All they ever do is sit on their chairs, eat, and talk to people on their holographic screens right in front of them – until wall-e knocks one guy off his chair. When they get knocked down – they can’t even walk let alone pick themselves up. It’s pretty sad – they just lay on the ground till some machine picks them up and puts them back on their chairs. Anyways when they get knocked down- they’re so confused. They start to notice things about their surroundings that were pretty obvious like how they have a pool and there are SO many advertisements all around them. It’s really creepy.
And then there’s artificial babies. You can just tell them what you want your kid to look like and they can make it happen. Just like now. You can have your baby artificially inseminated by some donor – that’s so weird. I thought reproducing was supposed to be this like ‘magical experience’ – what happened to back in the days – when you just reproduced with someone you fell in love with or w.e. I mean you can even have someone else carry your own baby – now who the hell came up with that! That’s really crazy. Everything that used to be so sacred back in the days (like sex) is now completely taken for granted. Our society even sells sex. That’s fucking gross. Our society is raising a whole bunch of uneducated assholes that know how easy it is to have sex with someone so they don’t even care about feelings anymore. It’s all so weird.
I didn’t understand the whole Abe Lincoln thing though. We talked a little about it in the discussion group and some people suggested that it was for the idea that even though you can have smart genes, you can still be incredibly dumb. If that is the parallel then I completely agree. I mean people before us were a lot smarter and actually did studying. Today we don’t study as much because so lazy and we let all the technology find the information for us. We don’t even know if what we’re reading is true or false. We just receive it and choose whether we like it or not.
Who are we kidding we don’t live meaningful lives and neither do the people in feed. In fact we all live lives far from meaningful – what a waste.
I guess I kind of see the parallels between Feed and our modern day teenage lives but in general I still feel Feed is way more exaggerated. Like the whole idea of the nice neighborhoods that pretty much can make the sun come and go whenever they want vs. poor neighborhoods that all share their uncontrolled days and nights. I feel like that might be a metaphor for how much easier life is for people who have money and how hard and ‘unexpected’ it is for people who don’t. How some things that don’t even matter to people who are well off, have a more valuable importance to those who are less fortunate. Or that’s probably not even the parallel for it – I don’t know.
Also the amount of marketing is ridiculous in the book. Anytime you think of something – you receive an advertisement for it, other things related to it or other items people look at who have previously looked at that item. The same thing goes for our society. Although we don’t have chips in our brains, we see advertisements everywhere we go – on billboards, transportation mobiles, cellphones, trains, tv, our computers, in music, on clothing, jewelry, etc. The feed is all around us and even on us.
I thought it was kind of ridiculous how in the book, they were all saying Coke a whole bunch of times to get free supplies thinking they were cheating the whole deal when really they just fell completely into it. It’s like now-a-days when people refer other people to things such as clubs of some sort they get discounts and so on so they keep telling more people thinking they’re benefitting themselves when really they’re only the companies’ source of making more money.
The artificial air factory was quite bizarre to me. I mean – the whole idea of getting rid of trees because of artificial air factories – god that’s scary. But I kind of see the metaphor with like libraries and how pretty soon no one’s really going to need them because we have all these other sources of information – I mean you can even find whole books online. And even movie theatres. One of your very few sources of watching movies was at the theatre – now you can go to blockbuster, order it from Netflix, see it on your computer, see it on your phone, and see it on your iPod. I mean nothing’s the same. We’re taking these interesting and entertaining ideas and making them super artificial and killing it by over-doing it. I’d like to one day go see a drive in movie – like how they used to do a long time ago. I’m sure they still have them I just don’t know where.
All the information they’ll ever need is sitting in their brains feed with extremely easy access. Like computers. We don’t even have to go to libraries or read through books to study – we can find online essays, go to sparknotes.com, dictionary.com, Wikipedia, etc. Everything is at the tip of our fingers. This reminds me of the movie Wall-e. In the movie, earth is no longer live-able so all humans live on this spaceship and you see them on chairs that move around so they don’t have to walk and something like feeds as a hologram right in front of them. All they ever do is sit on their chairs, eat, and talk to people on their holographic screens right in front of them – until wall-e knocks one guy off his chair. When they get knocked down – they can’t even walk let alone pick themselves up. It’s pretty sad – they just lay on the ground till some machine picks them up and puts them back on their chairs. Anyways when they get knocked down- they’re so confused. They start to notice things about their surroundings that were pretty obvious like how they have a pool and there are SO many advertisements all around them. It’s really creepy.
And then there’s artificial babies. You can just tell them what you want your kid to look like and they can make it happen. Just like now. You can have your baby artificially inseminated by some donor – that’s so weird. I thought reproducing was supposed to be this like ‘magical experience’ – what happened to back in the days – when you just reproduced with someone you fell in love with or w.e. I mean you can even have someone else carry your own baby – now who the hell came up with that! That’s really crazy. Everything that used to be so sacred back in the days (like sex) is now completely taken for granted. Our society even sells sex. That’s fucking gross. Our society is raising a whole bunch of uneducated assholes that know how easy it is to have sex with someone so they don’t even care about feelings anymore. It’s all so weird.
I didn’t understand the whole Abe Lincoln thing though. We talked a little about it in the discussion group and some people suggested that it was for the idea that even though you can have smart genes, you can still be incredibly dumb. If that is the parallel then I completely agree. I mean people before us were a lot smarter and actually did studying. Today we don’t study as much because so lazy and we let all the technology find the information for us. We don’t even know if what we’re reading is true or false. We just receive it and choose whether we like it or not.
Who are we kidding we don’t live meaningful lives and neither do the people in feed. In fact we all live lives far from meaningful – what a waste.
Thursday, October 8, 2009
HW 11 Self-Experiment 1
So for this little self experiment I decided to take an idea from Andy's list of suggestions on either previous experiments or his own ideas.
On Wednesday nights, I try to get most or all of my homework out the way (usually). I decided to not do any of it and from the moment I walked into my house, I didn't do anything but listen to my iPod, watch T.V, go online, sign on facebook, text people, make phone calls, and played video games. I did this until the normal time I usually go to sleep. At the end of the day (right before I went to sleep) I felt so sickeing of all the D.R.D's. I thought it was even more sickening that I went so overboard with it. I felt so fucking stupid, like I did nothing productive. I usually make time out of my day for me to sit, think, and analyze my own life but I found it too hard and distracting. Too much noise. I felt so brainless. I knew from this point - kids do need time limits on D.R.D's (only if they don't know how to manage their time with technology and studies, etc).
Today, right after I got home from internship, I turned off my iPod, left my cellphone alone, unplugged my T.V (literally), and began homework. Unfortunately I realized I do have to turn on the computer to do my homework and it has been fairly easy not to go to other websites besides any regarding hw ones. I feel much better. I feel realxed and at ease. But I also feel like a cheater because I'm still on the computer - but the clicking of the keyboard is getting pretty irritating. I want to stop and just like read or something so I feel better. I feel better than I do with D.R.D's.
That's weird because I argued before that I feel better with them. Maybe by better I meant I don't like change so when I don't have my D.R.D's for certain specific times - it feels strange and weird. A feeling I'm not used to. I didn't think it had such a huge impact on me though. Also, I'm not a hardcore D.R.D person. Yes I have an iPod and a cellphone but I rarely listen to my iPod during the day - it's usually on the train going and coming home - as for my cellphone - I never and i mean NEVER talk on the phone. I just don't like it - never have. I text instead. And even so - I ignore a lot of texts but the ones I do answer to - I'm never ALL into it. I'm not fully immersed into texting to the point where I forget who I am or where I am. It's never that serious. And I do have facebook - but I don't really check it that often. I never even liked the idea of it. I only got a facebook because someone who I value as a person asked me to get one - this doesn't mean I'm trying to say taht I don't enjoy the time I spend on there - I do. I'm just saying it's not something I'm all that interested into. Like I never just sign in to sign in. I check my email and get notifications sent there and only when I'm interested in the notifications do I sign in. A lot of teens I know are obsessed with facebook, obsessed with talking on the phone, listen to their iPods way more than I do, etc. I don't have any T.V shows I really like - so watching T.V is not all that important to me (unless I'm in a movie-mode where I just feel like watching movies). And I hardly ever sign on - and when I do - I hardly ever respond to people who i.m (instant message) me. So you see in conclusion - I still don't think digitalization itself is bad for you - I just think too much is nauseating and its healthy to take breaks from it every so often.
On Wednesday nights, I try to get most or all of my homework out the way (usually). I decided to not do any of it and from the moment I walked into my house, I didn't do anything but listen to my iPod, watch T.V, go online, sign on facebook, text people, make phone calls, and played video games. I did this until the normal time I usually go to sleep. At the end of the day (right before I went to sleep) I felt so sickeing of all the D.R.D's. I thought it was even more sickening that I went so overboard with it. I felt so fucking stupid, like I did nothing productive. I usually make time out of my day for me to sit, think, and analyze my own life but I found it too hard and distracting. Too much noise. I felt so brainless. I knew from this point - kids do need time limits on D.R.D's (only if they don't know how to manage their time with technology and studies, etc).
Today, right after I got home from internship, I turned off my iPod, left my cellphone alone, unplugged my T.V (literally), and began homework. Unfortunately I realized I do have to turn on the computer to do my homework and it has been fairly easy not to go to other websites besides any regarding hw ones. I feel much better. I feel realxed and at ease. But I also feel like a cheater because I'm still on the computer - but the clicking of the keyboard is getting pretty irritating. I want to stop and just like read or something so I feel better. I feel better than I do with D.R.D's.
That's weird because I argued before that I feel better with them. Maybe by better I meant I don't like change so when I don't have my D.R.D's for certain specific times - it feels strange and weird. A feeling I'm not used to. I didn't think it had such a huge impact on me though. Also, I'm not a hardcore D.R.D person. Yes I have an iPod and a cellphone but I rarely listen to my iPod during the day - it's usually on the train going and coming home - as for my cellphone - I never and i mean NEVER talk on the phone. I just don't like it - never have. I text instead. And even so - I ignore a lot of texts but the ones I do answer to - I'm never ALL into it. I'm not fully immersed into texting to the point where I forget who I am or where I am. It's never that serious. And I do have facebook - but I don't really check it that often. I never even liked the idea of it. I only got a facebook because someone who I value as a person asked me to get one - this doesn't mean I'm trying to say taht I don't enjoy the time I spend on there - I do. I'm just saying it's not something I'm all that interested into. Like I never just sign in to sign in. I check my email and get notifications sent there and only when I'm interested in the notifications do I sign in. A lot of teens I know are obsessed with facebook, obsessed with talking on the phone, listen to their iPods way more than I do, etc. I don't have any T.V shows I really like - so watching T.V is not all that important to me (unless I'm in a movie-mode where I just feel like watching movies). And I hardly ever sign on - and when I do - I hardly ever respond to people who i.m (instant message) me. So you see in conclusion - I still don't think digitalization itself is bad for you - I just think too much is nauseating and its healthy to take breaks from it every so often.
Monday, October 5, 2009
HW 10 - Informal research *Edited
(Source)
This article from the NY times suggests that we should use the speaker phone more, talk less, or text more rather than putting our ears to these cellular devices in which give out minimum yet still harmful (in the long-run) radiations.
I think this idea may help minimize the amount of radiation our cellphones give out and as a result will be less harmful pertaining to our health, but this alternative won't make the addiction any better. If anything - its promoting the use of more digital devices because in a way its like advertising how its not ALL that bad for you.
(Source)
Wikipedia says something quite different than the times article. Wikipedia explains how there's not even enough convinving evidence to prove that cellphones cause this type of damage. "The World Health Organization, based upon the consensus view of the scientific and medical communities, states that cancer is unlikely to be caused by cellular phones or their base stations and that reviews have found no convincing evidence for other health effects." (source above).
I think this actually might be the case. Honestly, who's the last person you heard of/knew that got cancer from the amount of radiation given out from their cellphone? Personally I know none and I think a lot of times people overlook/study things. I feel like most studies are more coincidental. Sure, cellphones do give out radiation which is harmful but are we really taking in so much to the point we're at risk for cancer? I don't know.
(Source)
Facebook is a highly addicting social network in which a lot of people rely on daily. "Average user has 130 friends on the site,
More than 6 billion minutes are spent on Facebook each day (worldwide), More than 40 million status updates each day, ... 70% of facebook users are outside the U.S. There are more than 65 million active users currently accessing Facebook through their mobile devices. People that use Facebook on their mobile devices are almost 50% more active on Facebook than non-mobile users."
I would have thought maybe at the very least 40% were in the US... That's quite ridiculous. I think this study supports a lot of our theorys/findings from our previous informal studies such as how much people value attention, how much people live their lives revolving around social interactions, how addicted we are to digital devices, etc.
(Source)
Studies show that people are capable of listening to music for hours at a time. Even some of the same songs. But they are not 'capable' of watching things for hours at a time. The ipod is merely used to listen to music rather than watch videos even though most people do indeed have ipods that hold videos.
Why is it that we can listen to songs for hours at a time (even on repeat) but can't do that with videos? What is it about our attention span, our ability to memorize songs and continuously enjoy them and not the same with videos, whats different about our vision vs. our hearing that we can keep going with sound but not with sight?
(Source)
People would rather watch tv than work out, play/watch sports, etc. "The study found that, outside of sleeping, the largest collective contributor to energy expenditure among the population was "driving a car," followed by "office work" and "watching TV," partly because so many people reported those activities. In contrast, leisure-time physical activity, such as jogging or playing basketball, accounted for only 5 percent of the population's total energy expenditure".
This is why Americans are so obese. We're definitely not as active as we used to be. I think mainly thanks to the amount of access we can obtain from different technology, we don't see the need to go outside for much anymore. We enjoy being lazy, we enjoy being distracted, we look for more distractions, we enjoy being able to escape the real world, we constantly fantasize and wish for better and are HARDLY ever grateful for what's in front of us. Damn.
This article from the NY times suggests that we should use the speaker phone more, talk less, or text more rather than putting our ears to these cellular devices in which give out minimum yet still harmful (in the long-run) radiations.
I think this idea may help minimize the amount of radiation our cellphones give out and as a result will be less harmful pertaining to our health, but this alternative won't make the addiction any better. If anything - its promoting the use of more digital devices because in a way its like advertising how its not ALL that bad for you.
(Source)
Wikipedia says something quite different than the times article. Wikipedia explains how there's not even enough convinving evidence to prove that cellphones cause this type of damage. "The World Health Organization, based upon the consensus view of the scientific and medical communities, states that cancer is unlikely to be caused by cellular phones or their base stations and that reviews have found no convincing evidence for other health effects." (source above).
I think this actually might be the case. Honestly, who's the last person you heard of/knew that got cancer from the amount of radiation given out from their cellphone? Personally I know none and I think a lot of times people overlook/study things. I feel like most studies are more coincidental. Sure, cellphones do give out radiation which is harmful but are we really taking in so much to the point we're at risk for cancer? I don't know.
(Source)
Facebook is a highly addicting social network in which a lot of people rely on daily. "Average user has 130 friends on the site,
More than 6 billion minutes are spent on Facebook each day (worldwide), More than 40 million status updates each day, ... 70% of facebook users are outside the U.S. There are more than 65 million active users currently accessing Facebook through their mobile devices. People that use Facebook on their mobile devices are almost 50% more active on Facebook than non-mobile users."
I would have thought maybe at the very least 40% were in the US... That's quite ridiculous. I think this study supports a lot of our theorys/findings from our previous informal studies such as how much people value attention, how much people live their lives revolving around social interactions, how addicted we are to digital devices, etc.
(Source)
Studies show that people are capable of listening to music for hours at a time. Even some of the same songs. But they are not 'capable' of watching things for hours at a time. The ipod is merely used to listen to music rather than watch videos even though most people do indeed have ipods that hold videos.
Why is it that we can listen to songs for hours at a time (even on repeat) but can't do that with videos? What is it about our attention span, our ability to memorize songs and continuously enjoy them and not the same with videos, whats different about our vision vs. our hearing that we can keep going with sound but not with sight?
(Source)
People would rather watch tv than work out, play/watch sports, etc. "The study found that, outside of sleeping, the largest collective contributor to energy expenditure among the population was "driving a car," followed by "office work" and "watching TV," partly because so many people reported those activities. In contrast, leisure-time physical activity, such as jogging or playing basketball, accounted for only 5 percent of the population's total energy expenditure".
This is why Americans are so obese. We're definitely not as active as we used to be. I think mainly thanks to the amount of access we can obtain from different technology, we don't see the need to go outside for much anymore. We enjoy being lazy, we enjoy being distracted, we look for more distractions, we enjoy being able to escape the real world, we constantly fantasize and wish for better and are HARDLY ever grateful for what's in front of us. Damn.
HW #9 - Reply's
Comment back on Rachel:
Rachel,
Thanks for the comment. I know you understood exactly where I was coming from by what you wrote in the comment (quoting me and connecting it to the way you feel). Glad you saw where I was coming from.
For the most part you just agreed with me on my pov of our use on digital representational devices, but it was helpful that you pointed out I should probably ask someone how I look – even though I already know how I look and you mentioned it too in your comment.
I think you need to critique me a lot better – you really didn’t tell me any areas to revise or possibly expand – which I’m sure there are plenty of places in my writing to do so. But when you said my post made you realize we don’t need technology to have fun – I think the point I was making was a bit of the opposite. I mean in general I know I can have fun without technology but my main point was how much fun I have with it. It’s almost like a necessity now-a-days. Like I really can’t live without most of these D.R.D’s. I wouldn’t say I’m addicted though – I just find much more enjoyment in my day when I hear music, or watching something I find interesting/funny, etc.
We both pretty much focused on how much we don’t want this for the future (future children .. little sisters, etc). Even though as you pointed out its being a total hypocrite. Amanda thinks technology has gone nowhere near its limits and believes by the time our children are born – technology would have greatly advanced – I do agree but I’m scared of the point she makes – our children will be much worse than we are. They’ll be walking zombies – that’s creepy.
So I’d say we’re both ‘interested’ in how it could be possible that we can find so much enjoyment in D.R.D’s but hardly show of the pleasurable emotions in our faces through our recordings.
Comment back on Amanda:
Amanda,
Thanks for commenting my blog. Also I strongly believe you really tried to think about what to say in your comment to me instead of just bullshitting one so much appreciated on that. I like your questions at the end of your comment and I like how smoothly you wrote the comment. I appreciate the time and effort you took out of your own life to complete this assignment.
I think it was helpful of you to build off of my thoughts and add on that by the time we have children – technology would have reached new heights and even so will become just as much most likely even more controlling than it already is. Kids’ll be walking around with earpieces glued to the side of their head. I can see the tumors culminating in deaths right now. =(
Towards the end you asked me if I composed myself while recording – well Amanda, I completely did. I mean, I did as I usually do but I did it knowing people will watch so I refused to allow myself to go into complete robot mode. It was creepy watching me stare so I chose not to ass some staring parts in. I agree with you – its completely embarrassing how far and deep I allow myself to zone out with D.R.D’s.
I think me and you were both focused on how we don’t allow ourselves to become completely embodied when we know we’re the center of attention. I agree with you, it’s sad that even during a time where you’re supposed to let people observe your true interaction with D.R.D’s, we still put on a show for them. I guess we’ll never really be able to get clear and concise insights from all our fake videos, huh?
You also focused more on the different things these devices allow you to do (in your case- escape from stress) whereas I went on about how stupid I looked being pulled in by these devices yet feeling a certain way when I’m personally interacting with them (with no one around).
I know we’re both interested if people may have subconsciously put on a show or if some people recorded and showed how they really were, true facial expressions and all. I think the assignment would have been more interesting if somehow someone else recorded us interacting with our D.R.D’s without us even knowing so that we could pull out the real emotions from our faces,etc.
Anyways, good writing. I’m sure we’ll be commenting again – so keep up the good work.
Rachel,
Thanks for the comment. I know you understood exactly where I was coming from by what you wrote in the comment (quoting me and connecting it to the way you feel). Glad you saw where I was coming from.
For the most part you just agreed with me on my pov of our use on digital representational devices, but it was helpful that you pointed out I should probably ask someone how I look – even though I already know how I look and you mentioned it too in your comment.
I think you need to critique me a lot better – you really didn’t tell me any areas to revise or possibly expand – which I’m sure there are plenty of places in my writing to do so. But when you said my post made you realize we don’t need technology to have fun – I think the point I was making was a bit of the opposite. I mean in general I know I can have fun without technology but my main point was how much fun I have with it. It’s almost like a necessity now-a-days. Like I really can’t live without most of these D.R.D’s. I wouldn’t say I’m addicted though – I just find much more enjoyment in my day when I hear music, or watching something I find interesting/funny, etc.
We both pretty much focused on how much we don’t want this for the future (future children .. little sisters, etc). Even though as you pointed out its being a total hypocrite. Amanda thinks technology has gone nowhere near its limits and believes by the time our children are born – technology would have greatly advanced – I do agree but I’m scared of the point she makes – our children will be much worse than we are. They’ll be walking zombies – that’s creepy.
So I’d say we’re both ‘interested’ in how it could be possible that we can find so much enjoyment in D.R.D’s but hardly show of the pleasurable emotions in our faces through our recordings.
Comment back on Amanda:
Amanda,
Thanks for commenting my blog. Also I strongly believe you really tried to think about what to say in your comment to me instead of just bullshitting one so much appreciated on that. I like your questions at the end of your comment and I like how smoothly you wrote the comment. I appreciate the time and effort you took out of your own life to complete this assignment.
I think it was helpful of you to build off of my thoughts and add on that by the time we have children – technology would have reached new heights and even so will become just as much most likely even more controlling than it already is. Kids’ll be walking around with earpieces glued to the side of their head. I can see the tumors culminating in deaths right now. =(
Towards the end you asked me if I composed myself while recording – well Amanda, I completely did. I mean, I did as I usually do but I did it knowing people will watch so I refused to allow myself to go into complete robot mode. It was creepy watching me stare so I chose not to ass some staring parts in. I agree with you – its completely embarrassing how far and deep I allow myself to zone out with D.R.D’s.
I think me and you were both focused on how we don’t allow ourselves to become completely embodied when we know we’re the center of attention. I agree with you, it’s sad that even during a time where you’re supposed to let people observe your true interaction with D.R.D’s, we still put on a show for them. I guess we’ll never really be able to get clear and concise insights from all our fake videos, huh?
You also focused more on the different things these devices allow you to do (in your case- escape from stress) whereas I went on about how stupid I looked being pulled in by these devices yet feeling a certain way when I’m personally interacting with them (with no one around).
I know we’re both interested if people may have subconsciously put on a show or if some people recorded and showed how they really were, true facial expressions and all. I think the assignment would have been more interesting if somehow someone else recorded us interacting with our D.R.D’s without us even knowing so that we could pull out the real emotions from our faces,etc.
Anyways, good writing. I’m sure we’ll be commenting again – so keep up the good work.
Wednesday, September 30, 2009
HW 8 - Comment on Triangle Partners' Video Project
Comment to Rachel:
Rachel,
Wow. You type really fast, I’m guessing you spend a lot more time on the computer than most people. I like that you had a phone call in your video but I’m amazed that you heard it ring or saw it light up or vibrate or whatever it did. I think it’s funny that your sister seems to be completely aware that there’s a video in front of you and is watching herself just stand there in your video. I like how she plays it off and picks up the cat – she’s younger than you right?
You say you’re completely oblivious to what’s going on around you. You’re listening to music on your ipod, and talking to your friends through facebook and i.ming. You have a very short attention span in this video. Your eyes are constantly jumping from one place of the screen to the next. You keep opening up your eyes wider indicating something must be intriguing and you can talk to someone on the phone and online at the same time. I like how you mention you’re completely sucked into the digital world. It’s kind of weird to see you be so into the computer and then pause – take off your headphones to pick up your phone – but then you go right back to being on the computer and I felt as though just for a brief moment, your cell-phone transported you right out of zombie-mode. Interesting being that your cell-phone too is a digital device. I guess since your interacting more with people, you seem more ‘normal’. I noticed you feel different about technology regarding either your younger sister or future child. You said you want them to be more active – just as our parents tell us- but you’d make an exception for ipod and cell-phone usage. Why is it so different from t.v though? I’d like to disagree with you when you say that your emotions aren’t changing – you smile at times, grin, make your eyes wider, etc. These different facial expressions (I’m guessing) mean a certain emotion you’re having while staring at your computer. For some reason most people tend to act stranger when a camera is on them. They seem more stiff – like they’re watching what they do so that people won’t find it embarrassing when others see it. You seem like you unconsciously know the cameras on you and refrain from doing something out of the ordinary. I look like that too in my video. We’re not the only ones though.
I disagree with you. If I do have children, seeing as how digital technology affects us, I would try to go harder on them in the sense that I’ll replace the iPod for a book. I don’t think I’ll let them have a T.V in their rooms, but instead maybe something more productive – like an exercise machine or something. It just seems so repetitive that our parents don’t want us always on our digital devices, and we say the same for our future kids. I think if I were to have a kid I’d make more of an effort to make them be more involved with anything I can think of – whether its sports (hopefully), or like I don’t know dancing or something active. This way they’ll be healthier, more in shape, build some social skills, and probably all around be much happier.
I guess you could think about what type of emotions specifically these digital devices allow you to feel. In your video you’re very quiet (except when you’re on the phone) but in your mind I bet a bunch of different thoughts entered your mind all at once. I also wonder what these thoughts are – can you even remember them? If you can’t, what does that show about the way technology affects us? What does this say about your ability to, just in general, think?
I think a lot of us are constantly putting on shows for others. We knew that people were going to watch these videos so we purposely or ‘unknowingly’ didn’t do anything that could raise a doubt to anyone’s mind about the people we are. I also think that it really is true – mainly because of the influence technology has on us, we don’t think – we repeat ideas we were taught ourselves. We make no new theories and attempt to develop our minds. I like this class because it helps me to step of my normal box and dig for thoughts. Not only dig for thoughts but pay attention to them. Not just think about them and let them go – as I know we all do when we’re being drawn in by our digital representational devices.
Thank you. I don’t think I would have been able to think about some of these things and try to understand them better if not for your video and post.
Comment to Amanda:
Amanda,
I’m guessing you’re in your living room because I didn’t see a bed or anything. Did you choose this place for a ‘nice recording background’ or is this the place you spend most your time interacting with DRD’s? I like how you showed your video game skills – you’re really good at that game. What kind of satisfaction do you get from it anyway? Also I wanted to mention that I liked how you incorporated what Andy taught today in class to further understand what he was saying.
In your video, you were talking to friends on the computer, playing video games, listening to your ipod, and texting? You seem to have noticed you’re wasting time and felt as though, at the time, it made you want more and more. You’re unsure of whether your usage of DRD’s play as an escape from your stress in reality. So I’m guessing you like having your mind completely immersed in whatever it is you’re digitally doing. Watching your video plays a part in making you feel like you’re reliving those meaningless wasteful moments. You like the fact that DRD’s can benefit you in certain ways but your opposed to having your future child use it as an escape – as you think you might be doing. You seem to think emotions determine the depth of a good conversation. You’re confused to whether or not deep conversations can be held not only face to face.
Just in general, I think deep conversations don’t have to be with facial expressions. As long as you’re thinking in your head and answering truthfully and honestly and developing ideas – I guess you’re having a ‘deep convo’. Your video and response makes me realize how often I wonder about what goes on in other people’s minds and how badly I wish I could see what they’re doing. A lot of people in their video showed what they were doing and then showed facial expressions which like relieved some of the wondering – but on your phone and with your iPod – I was curious to know what you were listening to and what kind of ‘deep conversations’ you were having. I agree, digital stuff can help take your mind off things, but only for a little while. We’re constantly looking for more stimulation to take our mind off of reality and temporarily avoid problems by dodging them until there are no other stimulations we find. It’s as if we’re mice – constantly searching for anything that lays ahead of us (in our case – things in hands reach – cellphones, ipods, videogames, computers, etc).
I notice you keep mentioning that the things you watched yourself do seem meaningless. I think it would be clearer to the reader if you can really tell us whether it’s meaningful or not to you and in what ways. If you could, what better ways would you suggest to yourself to try out that won’t be such a ‘waste’ of time? In class you said you do gymnastics, do you think more time stretching at home would help you become a better gymnast? Is there anything else specifically you would like to focus more time on or devote time towards?
After seeing many videos in general – you get tired of seeing earphones plugged into every person you watch. You start to wonder what gets so boring about life that people have to find something to watch or do to get their minds off of ‘things’. Like me choosing to plug in my earphones is a choice I make to not develop my mind. It’s a choice to take the easier way out in life – making me lazier and not helpful towards me building different skills with my mind (ie: analyzing, etc) . We’re so out of touch with the world around us, we forget to appreciate the details in our lives. I noticed that ever since the day Andy held class on the roof, I look up at the sky more often to notice the shape the clouds are in, or what the sky in general looks like. I can usually predict myself how the day will turn out to be just by that. I start to think about how I’m feeling walking down streets, and pay more attention to the different things you can smell in new York that we’ve become so accustomed to (like when I go to duane reade to get something to drink after volleyball practice – I notice the smell of hot dogs from the guy on the corner). It’s these smells we forget to appreciate that we even have the ability to smell every day. It may not be meaningful but at least I can be slightly more in touch with my surroundings.
Your video-gaming skills are pretty advanced. Connecting the things you learn in class to what youre doing from homework is always a plus. Good job!
Rachel,
Wow. You type really fast, I’m guessing you spend a lot more time on the computer than most people. I like that you had a phone call in your video but I’m amazed that you heard it ring or saw it light up or vibrate or whatever it did. I think it’s funny that your sister seems to be completely aware that there’s a video in front of you and is watching herself just stand there in your video. I like how she plays it off and picks up the cat – she’s younger than you right?
You say you’re completely oblivious to what’s going on around you. You’re listening to music on your ipod, and talking to your friends through facebook and i.ming. You have a very short attention span in this video. Your eyes are constantly jumping from one place of the screen to the next. You keep opening up your eyes wider indicating something must be intriguing and you can talk to someone on the phone and online at the same time. I like how you mention you’re completely sucked into the digital world. It’s kind of weird to see you be so into the computer and then pause – take off your headphones to pick up your phone – but then you go right back to being on the computer and I felt as though just for a brief moment, your cell-phone transported you right out of zombie-mode. Interesting being that your cell-phone too is a digital device. I guess since your interacting more with people, you seem more ‘normal’. I noticed you feel different about technology regarding either your younger sister or future child. You said you want them to be more active – just as our parents tell us- but you’d make an exception for ipod and cell-phone usage. Why is it so different from t.v though? I’d like to disagree with you when you say that your emotions aren’t changing – you smile at times, grin, make your eyes wider, etc. These different facial expressions (I’m guessing) mean a certain emotion you’re having while staring at your computer. For some reason most people tend to act stranger when a camera is on them. They seem more stiff – like they’re watching what they do so that people won’t find it embarrassing when others see it. You seem like you unconsciously know the cameras on you and refrain from doing something out of the ordinary. I look like that too in my video. We’re not the only ones though.
I disagree with you. If I do have children, seeing as how digital technology affects us, I would try to go harder on them in the sense that I’ll replace the iPod for a book. I don’t think I’ll let them have a T.V in their rooms, but instead maybe something more productive – like an exercise machine or something. It just seems so repetitive that our parents don’t want us always on our digital devices, and we say the same for our future kids. I think if I were to have a kid I’d make more of an effort to make them be more involved with anything I can think of – whether its sports (hopefully), or like I don’t know dancing or something active. This way they’ll be healthier, more in shape, build some social skills, and probably all around be much happier.
I guess you could think about what type of emotions specifically these digital devices allow you to feel. In your video you’re very quiet (except when you’re on the phone) but in your mind I bet a bunch of different thoughts entered your mind all at once. I also wonder what these thoughts are – can you even remember them? If you can’t, what does that show about the way technology affects us? What does this say about your ability to, just in general, think?
I think a lot of us are constantly putting on shows for others. We knew that people were going to watch these videos so we purposely or ‘unknowingly’ didn’t do anything that could raise a doubt to anyone’s mind about the people we are. I also think that it really is true – mainly because of the influence technology has on us, we don’t think – we repeat ideas we were taught ourselves. We make no new theories and attempt to develop our minds. I like this class because it helps me to step of my normal box and dig for thoughts. Not only dig for thoughts but pay attention to them. Not just think about them and let them go – as I know we all do when we’re being drawn in by our digital representational devices.
Thank you. I don’t think I would have been able to think about some of these things and try to understand them better if not for your video and post.
Comment to Amanda:
Amanda,
I’m guessing you’re in your living room because I didn’t see a bed or anything. Did you choose this place for a ‘nice recording background’ or is this the place you spend most your time interacting with DRD’s? I like how you showed your video game skills – you’re really good at that game. What kind of satisfaction do you get from it anyway? Also I wanted to mention that I liked how you incorporated what Andy taught today in class to further understand what he was saying.
In your video, you were talking to friends on the computer, playing video games, listening to your ipod, and texting? You seem to have noticed you’re wasting time and felt as though, at the time, it made you want more and more. You’re unsure of whether your usage of DRD’s play as an escape from your stress in reality. So I’m guessing you like having your mind completely immersed in whatever it is you’re digitally doing. Watching your video plays a part in making you feel like you’re reliving those meaningless wasteful moments. You like the fact that DRD’s can benefit you in certain ways but your opposed to having your future child use it as an escape – as you think you might be doing. You seem to think emotions determine the depth of a good conversation. You’re confused to whether or not deep conversations can be held not only face to face.
Just in general, I think deep conversations don’t have to be with facial expressions. As long as you’re thinking in your head and answering truthfully and honestly and developing ideas – I guess you’re having a ‘deep convo’. Your video and response makes me realize how often I wonder about what goes on in other people’s minds and how badly I wish I could see what they’re doing. A lot of people in their video showed what they were doing and then showed facial expressions which like relieved some of the wondering – but on your phone and with your iPod – I was curious to know what you were listening to and what kind of ‘deep conversations’ you were having. I agree, digital stuff can help take your mind off things, but only for a little while. We’re constantly looking for more stimulation to take our mind off of reality and temporarily avoid problems by dodging them until there are no other stimulations we find. It’s as if we’re mice – constantly searching for anything that lays ahead of us (in our case – things in hands reach – cellphones, ipods, videogames, computers, etc).
I notice you keep mentioning that the things you watched yourself do seem meaningless. I think it would be clearer to the reader if you can really tell us whether it’s meaningful or not to you and in what ways. If you could, what better ways would you suggest to yourself to try out that won’t be such a ‘waste’ of time? In class you said you do gymnastics, do you think more time stretching at home would help you become a better gymnast? Is there anything else specifically you would like to focus more time on or devote time towards?
After seeing many videos in general – you get tired of seeing earphones plugged into every person you watch. You start to wonder what gets so boring about life that people have to find something to watch or do to get their minds off of ‘things’. Like me choosing to plug in my earphones is a choice I make to not develop my mind. It’s a choice to take the easier way out in life – making me lazier and not helpful towards me building different skills with my mind (ie: analyzing, etc) . We’re so out of touch with the world around us, we forget to appreciate the details in our lives. I noticed that ever since the day Andy held class on the roof, I look up at the sky more often to notice the shape the clouds are in, or what the sky in general looks like. I can usually predict myself how the day will turn out to be just by that. I start to think about how I’m feeling walking down streets, and pay more attention to the different things you can smell in new York that we’ve become so accustomed to (like when I go to duane reade to get something to drink after volleyball practice – I notice the smell of hot dogs from the guy on the corner). It’s these smells we forget to appreciate that we even have the ability to smell every day. It may not be meaningful but at least I can be slightly more in touch with my surroundings.
Your video-gaming skills are pretty advanced. Connecting the things you learn in class to what youre doing from homework is always a plus. Good job!
Sunday, September 27, 2009
HW 6 - Video Project
I honestly think I look like a fucking retard. I can’t help but think how weird it looks to be watching myself. It makes me feel very uncomfortable. Very out of place. Like other people are watching me watching me. I don’t like the way I look at all or what I’m doing or how my facial expressions are. I’m critiquing myself in every aspect. I don’t like it.
If this is a large part of what my living physical experience is then I don’t feel too good about that. It’s weird because watching me and how I act with these digital representation devices looks so out of the ordinary to me but actually doing them feels completely different. I love the feeling when I’m using them and not watching myself do so, I dislike the strange feeling I get when I’m watching myself. I wonder if when people watch me interact with technology, they think I look that stupid and weird. I wonder what kind of feelings they feel when watching me. This being a big part of what I do seems like a very big waste of my life.
Honestly I know that I don’t want them to spend a lot of time doing this but the truth is I know they will. To see them always on these devices, I feel like our generation is going to tell future generations how much we regret not doing so many physical activities and how we too were like them 24/7 on their devices but they’re going to look at us like ‘whatever’. I wonder if our generation is going to grow out of this technological stage or are we going to be addicted to our phones, computers, TV’s, iPods’, etc till we’re in our death bed. That’ll look pretty weird. To die old in your death bed with your iPod on.
I think what’s happening on the digital devices – like exactly what is going through our minds is more along the lines of satisfaction/ enjoyment. But this is not the way it seems when we watch ourselves doing so. While watching myself, it looks like I’m bored and I’m looking for stuff to do constantly.
I have no real opinion about the wii I guess until I see someone spending their time on it. I’ve seen people up close playing the wii and even played so myself and to me it seems more interesting and I think although all these digital devices are so addicting, time-consuming, and an escape – the wii might be some sort of better alternative. Like if we had to choose a digital device, the wii would be the best pick. Because although you’re fully ‘into’ these video games, you’re still being active – which is better than not being active at all.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

